I wouldn’t mind horse meat on the menu

Increasingly consumers don’t connect their food and where it comes from

Lisa Markwell
Thursday 07 February 2013 21:00

Surprise! Your cheap, grey, uniformly textured and anonymously flavoured frozen supermarket burger contains horse meat. Since it was reported that Tesco Everyday Value burgers has been found to contain horsemeat, there’s been outrage and wisecracking in equal measures (although presumably not from people who eat Tesco Everyday Value burgers).

Excuse my lack of sympathy – but what did you think they were made of? Frankly, horse meat is a far more appealing prospect, nutrition-wise, than the mechanically recovered cow bums and lamb nostrils. By now I expect you’ll have heard every horsemeat joke and pun you could imagine… and some you couldn’t, if you’re on Twitter. But once the laughter has subsided, there is a serious point to all this.

I know from friends that have eaten it, that good quality horse meat is rather like venison – lean, dark and with a good flavour. It’s no accident that in Paris (where cheval has been on menus since forever), the meat is having a renaissance in restaurants like Le Taxi Jaune, thanks to a young chef with big ideas. Then again, I imagine the meat that ended up in the economy burgers was hardly thoroughbred.

Supermarkets – and indeed all food outlets – must label everything they sell correctly and clearly. It’s astonishing that Tesco would accept a meat product unquestioningly. If they’re getting the components or finished product from a supplier, they can use their oft-touted heavyweight power to demand accurate information. The implications for our health of untraceable, unidentified meat are deeply worrying.

But as important is the disconnect that consumers have, increasingly, between their food and where it comes from. If you buy a circle (or rectangle) of protein cloaked in cellophane, you could almost be forgiven for not connecting it to an animal. Almost.

If you eat meat (and my lifelong-vegetarian colleagues are feeling pretty smug right about now), why is horse less palatable than cow or sheep or pig? It’s no good hiding behind ludicrous ideas that horses are in some way cuter or more intelligent. Or that we have a special relationship with them because we ride them. If horses weren’t herbivores, I can imagine a few that would have no problem biting a lump out of their rider.

The simple truth is that we should be striving to eat recognisable food, from reputable providers and with a sense of responsibility from whence it came. I’m all for horse – perhaps one of those enterprising, oh-so-trendy haute burger bars in London should seize the moment and put it on the menu?

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments