The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission.

France and Italy could be the next European economies to crash

Denied the option of devaluation, both countries have relied on debt-funded public spending to maintain economic activity and living standards. The people and their representatives refuse to face reality

Satyajit Das
Sunday 29 May 2016 13:14 BST
The failure to reform after the financial crisis in the eurozone could hit the French economy hard
The failure to reform after the financial crisis in the eurozone could hit the French economy hard

Certain diseases attack the peripheries before vectoring in on vital organs. Following a similar trajectory is the European debt crisis, moving ever closer to the core. Italy and France are now especially vulnerable.

Defenders argue that Italy and France are large modern nations, with enviable economic pedigree. They are, respectively, the 13th and 9th largest economies in the world; gross domestic product per capita in 2014 is estimated at $34,500 (£23,590) and $40,400 (£27,624).

They have large populations, an educated and productive workforce, well developed infrastructure and considerable economic and social capital. Both countries are major agricultural and industrial powers, strong in advanced technical products, luxury goods, food processing, pharmaceuticals and fashion. Both are major exporters and significant tourist destinations.

Eurozone deal brings debt relief for Greece

France even has a favourable demographic outlook, with a birth rate just above replacement level mainly among its immigrant population. They are simply too large to fail.

But Italy and France share problems of slow growth, unemployment, poor public finances and structural problems. They have found it difficult to reform and face an increasingly tough political environment.

Italian total real economy debt (that is, government, household and business) is around 259 per cent of GDP, up 55 per cent since 2007. France’s equivalent debt is around 280 per cent of GDP, up 66 per cent since 2007. This ignores unfunded pension and healthcare obligations as well as contingent commitments to Eurozone bailouts. Debt will increase in critical levels quickly without corrective action.

France and Italy cannot avoid a financial crisis in an environment of low growth and low inflation. Real GDP growth would need to be around twice the current projected rates to stabilise and then reduce government debt-to-GDP ratios.

The required fiscal adjustment to start reducing government debt is around 2 per cent of GDP, which would reduce the growth needed to reduce leverage.

A combination of weak economic activity and low inflation is causing Italy’s debt trajectory to spiral upwards, despite austerity and a primary surplus of 2 per cent of GDP. In France, there is no sign that the budget is likely to be in surplus in the near future.

The real problem is the lack of competitiveness, and underlying many of these problems is the single currency.

Before the 2015 fall in the euro, after the European Central Bank introduced negative interest rates and quantitative easing, Italy and France were faced with a 15-25 per cent overvalued currency. This was compounded by the high leverage to the exchange rate for export competitiveness.

Italy has a gearing of over 60 per cent to the exchange rate, due to the nature of its exports, compared to around 40 per cent for Germany. Denied the option of devaluation to maintain international competitiveness, both countries have relied on debt-funded public spending to maintain economic activity and living standards.

In the absence of a favourable exchange rate, Italy and France face the difficult task of large internal cost reductions to regain competitiveness.

As the experience of Greece, Spain, Portugal and Ireland illustrates, this is a brutal and not always successful process. The adjustment would be assisted by strong export markets. But low growth in developed and emerging markets as both private and public sectors try to deleverage means that global demand is likely to remain muted.

In early 2015, in an interview with the Italian state TV network RAI, the then Greek Finance Minister Yanis Varoufakis argued that the euro was fragile like a house of cards. It would collapse if Greece withdrew or was forced out on the single currency.

He pointedly told his hosts that, “Italian officials – I can't tell you from which big institution – approached me to tell me they backed us but they can't tell the truth because Italy also risks bankruptcy and they are afraid of the reaction from Germany”.

His observation that Italy’s debt levels were unsustainable drew an immediate response from Italian Economy Minister Pier Carlo Padoan, who tweeted that Varoufakis's remarks were “out of place”. Italy's debt was “solid and sustainable”, he said.

The response was characteristic of Italian and French denial of the precariousness of their position. There is no acknowledgement of poor economic performance, high and rising debt levels, unacceptable fiscal outlook, and the need for far-reaching structural reforms.

There is no willingness to address the problems of the euro and the incompatibility of monetary union and a single currency with national fiscal management and sovereign independence among eurozone members. Both the population and their representatives refuse to face reality.

Cheaper energy prices combined with low government borrowing costs and a fall in the Euro, driven by the actions of the European Central Bank, cannot hide these deep-seated and unresolved problems forever.

Satyajit Das is a former banker and author. His latest book is ‘A Banquet of Consequences

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in