The most uncomfortable truth about the yellow vests protests is that Macron can never offer what they actually want

To the demands of the gilets jaunes for participation in decision-making and greater control over their own lives, Macron has no response except declarations of vague intentions for ‘consultations’

Aurelie Dianara
Paris, France
Thursday 13 December 2018 12:19
Paris Protests: 'gilet jaunes' protesters interviewed on the streets of the French capital

The next few days will be crucial for the gilets jaunes (yellow vests), the French protest movement who have been taking to the streets in opposition to President Macron’s policies – namely increasing fuel prices and the high cost of living. The protesters find themselves at a crossroads. Will the movement continue to grow? Or will it capitulate in the face of the government’s persistent intimidation and false concessions? The answer remains to be seen. For now, however, the gilets jaunes seem quite determined to keep up the fight.

Last Saturday was a decisive day for the movement. After three weeks of roadblocks on intersections and roundabouts, “snail operations” to slow traffic, direct action to defy motorway tolls, pickets of petrol stations, shopping malls, ports and logistics hubs, and huge mobilisations in Paris and other large cities every weekend, the movement demonstrated sizeable strength as 135,000 people took to the streets for a fourth day of protests.

Despite threats from the government that protesters would be met with harsh repression, and despite the government’s tentative announcement that the raise in petrol taxes would be scrapped, Saturday’s “Act IV” of mobilisation confirmed that the yellow vests’ demands are greater than the simple question of fuel prices. By now they have expanded to become far more radical - this is a movement for social and economic justice, against a system that punishes the poor and favours the rich, pushing the issue of inequality to the forefront of French politics.

The movement also now includes university and high school students protesting about the introduction of an elitist system of selection in universities and the increase in tuition fees for foreign students. Over the past week, hundreds of schools and university buildings have been occupied. Union members in the public sector, including ambulance drivers and firemen, have also joined the mobilisation, as well as high-profile anti-racist organisations such as Verite pour Adama, which was set up following the death in 2016 of 24-year-old Adama Traore in police custody and campaigns on the issue of police brutality.

On Saturday thousands of protesters also took to the streets for a “climate march”, despite the government’s attempts to get the organisers to cancel the demonstration by insisting that there can be no climate justice without social justice – thus expressing their support for the yellow vests’ movement. Several trade unions have called for strikes and demonstrations in the coming days.

The movement now cuts across broad sections of society, across professions and geography as well as race, age and gender. The brutal repression against the movement – many people were injured Saturday and over 2,000 people were arrested; the shocking images of high-school students forced to their knees by the police have spread far and wide on social media – is only prompting demonstrations and actions of solidarity across France and beyond.

On Monday, Macron made a much-awaited speech to the nation purporting to meet some of the gilets jaunes demands: raising the minimum wage by €100 per month as of January and abolishing tax on low-income pensions and overtime work. In reality, the concessions count for nothing. The minimum wage rise only anticipates increases already scheduled over the remainder of Macron’s government. Moreover, the burden of paying for these measures will fall solely on the working taxpayer; as Macron specified that employers will not pay a cent more. Most importantly, Macron has refused to reply to calls to bring back the solidarity wealth tax he abolished when he took office, explicitly stating that it was necessary to encourage entrepreneurship. In other words, he is not changing course.

His speech was received coldly by the yellow vests. First, because they demand much more radical fiscal reforms: the wealth tax, but also the introduction of a radically progressive tax system and a maximum salary for the richest – including for government officials and MPs.

But the movement is not just about economic justice. It is also about democracy. To the demands of the gilets jaunes for greater participation in decision-making, for greater control over their own lives, Macron has no response except declarations of vague intentions to launch a “wide consultation” on ecological issues and taxation. If a defining feature of neoliberalism has been the hollowing out of democracy, the result of this is that people are left with no means of expressing their dissent.

As things currently stand, huge numbers of French people have seen their living conditions decline, and regardless of whether they voted for Macron or not they have no other tools with which to hold him account. One of the key ideas that now dominate the roadblocks and mobilisations is the creation of a “citizens’ assembly” – a new institution that would truly represent the French people and wield real power – and the inauguration of a system of referendum of citizens’ initiative to abrogate old laws, propose new laws, modify the constitution and revoke any elected representative, from the local mayor to the MPs and the president. In order to obtain concrete progress in that direction, there are therefore no options but to step up the mobilisations.

Support free-thinking journalism and attend Independent events

Macron’s response yesterday merely adds further insult to injury. Crumbs and apologies will not be enough to quell the gilets jaunes’ anger. Protests are continuing, and the movement will be on the streets again this Saturday for “Act V”, named “the day of mourning” in reference to the victims of the attack that took place in Strasbourg last night.

But the sweeping change the movement demands is more than Macron can ever offer; it is his political project and the politics he represents that has failed the population of France. As elsewhere in Europe, neoliberalism is facing a potentially terminal crisis. The forces of the left must step into the wake of this crisis and seize the moment to make radical progressive change, or people will continue to suffer, and reactionary forces will continue to feed off their misery. The only way out is to break entirely with the status quo: Macron must go, as the protesters say –Macron, demission!”

Aurelie Dianara is a Paris-based academic and activist who sits on the national committee of Potere al Popolo, Italy

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in