Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

I was wrong about Jeremy Corbyn

The Labour leader did much better in the election than I expected. I need to understand and learn from my mistakes

John Rentoul
Thursday 29 June 2017 12:29 BST
Yes, I underestimated Corbyn’s appeal
Yes, I underestimated Corbyn’s appeal (Jack Taylor/Getty Images)

I was wrong about Jeremy Corbyn. I had already been wrong about him twice. I thought he would come fourth in the Labour leadership election in 2015, and I thought that, when he was exposed to the British public in an election campaign, Labour’s support would go down.

But I do try to learn from my mistakes, and so, knowing that I had been wrong about him, I tried to offset my own bias. I didn’t do a good job. I looked at all those polls and forecasting models pointing towards a Conservative majority of 100 or more, and I thought it would be less than that. I said the majority would be 78. Hopeless.

So now I will have to try harder to learn from my latest mistake. I put too much weight on assumptions for which there was little evidence. My colleague Jon Stone listed some of them this morning. One was that opinion polls tend to overstate Labour support. They have in the past, but most pollsters adjusted their methods after the last election. They seem to have overdone the correction. There was no way of knowing that, but I shouldn’t have assumed that, if there were an error, it would be to overstate Labour.

Jon also lists “Voters will never vote for left-wing policies”. I thought I was aware of the problems with that kind of simplistic assumption. I was well aware that some supposedly left-wing policies are popular, but I was confused, torn between pointing out that there is nothing left wing about public ownership and imagining that people would balk at adding to the national debt to pay for it.

General Election 2017: 6AM results - hung parliament confirmed

None of that matters. People think their gas and electricity bills are too expensive, and that the Government ought to do something about it. And they are sentimental about privatisation of rail and mail. People are also more worried about student debt than the question of who will pay for such a huge subsidy to better-off graduates.

I thought, too, that John McDonnell wanting an insurrection to bring down capitalism would go down badly with the median voter. It turned out that the median voter was pretty fed up with capitalism and didn’t mind a bit of anti-establishment rhetoric.

I also believed the polls when they said that Theresa May was preferred to Corbyn as prime minister, and that she had a particular advantage on Brexit, paying for economic promises and national security. But there were other things going on at the same time, above all a sense of compassion, enthusiasm and optimism, which compared badly with the emotional flatness of the Tory campaign.

I wasn’t relying just on opinion polls, of course. Labour did very badly in the local elections on 4 May. Those were real votes in real ballot boxes. I even met real voters. I came across Labour voters who liked Theresa May and others who didn’t like Corbyn. But I assumed May was more popular than she was. I thought British voters rather liked her stiffness and reserve. They may have told pollsters they preferred her to Corbyn, but it seems they don’t like her that much.

So, yes, I underestimated Corbyn’s appeal. I allowed my disagreement with his policies to colour my assumptions about what other voters would think about them. But I was not completely wrong. Labour came nowhere near being the largest party, and was even further away from winning a majority of its own. I still think another leader – goodness knows who, though – will be needed next time.

But the important thing for me is to understand my mistakes and to learn from them.

You can listen to John read and discuss his piece here.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in