Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

YouTube pranksters ‘expose royal commentators’ with fake interview quotes

They were told that their comments would be published immediately after interview with Meghan Markle and Prince Harry was broadcast

Gustaf Kilander
Washington, DC
Sunday 07 March 2021 11:56 GMT
Related video: Meghan Markle says it’s ‘liberating’ to be able to speak for herself
Leer en Español

YouTubers Josh Pieters and Archie Manners appear to have convinced four royal commentators to give their opinion on the interview between Oprah Winfrey and Prince Harry and Meghan Markle before it had even been broadcast.

The YouTube duo paid the Queen's former press secretary Dickie Arbiter, the editor of Majesty magazine Ingrid Seward, and royal commentators Richard Fitzwilliams and Victoria Arbiter to give their opinions.

They were told that their comments would be published immediately after the interview was broadcast. The interview will air Sunday in the US and on Monday in the UK.

They gave comments and shared opinions as if they had seen the interview when in fact they hadn't.

Follow Harry and Meghan news live: Latest updates as Oprah interview to air

"In the interview, to my mind, this was an actress giving one of her great performances. From start to finish, Meghan was acting," Ms Seward said in the YouTube video published Friday.

Ms Arbiter said Ms Winfrey asked "the tough questions. She had to ask the tough questions".

Mr Fitzwilliams said Ms Winfrey "gave them an easy ride. She was totally sympathetic, and there was a great deal in it that the palace will find deeply concerning".

Mr Manners told Insider that no one they contacted to share their thoughts rejected the idea.

He said: "I suppose what we were putting to the test was, given that they influence public opinion, and particularly at a time where public opinion is so divided on this issue, whether they had any insights worth listening to."

Mr Pieters told the outlet that "people are willing to say things that aren't necessarily true," adding that the video was "purely to experiment whether people would talk about something that hadn't happened yet in a sector that they are meant to be experts in, or they claim to be experts in".

Mr Manners said that the video "was a look at these commentators who are shaping public opinion, and it's up to viewers to decide whether they are qualified to share that opinion. And perhaps this video puts a different perspective into what these people are doing for money".

The video has surpassed 200,000 views on YouTube. Mr Pieters said they handed the royal commentators "facts, which weren't facts, and they spoke about them as facts".

Through his management, Mr Arbiter told The Independent that the interview request from the YouTubers “was deliberately misleading and a ‘scam’. I commented only on clips already in global circulation, but my interview was edited so as to imply I was speculating on the full programme interview. I was not speculating. I do not speculate”.

Calling it a “sting,” Mr Fitzwilliams told The Independent: “The arrangement was that the comments would be broadcast depending on what was in the interview, so nothing inappropriate would have appeared from anyone contributing.

“We had by then seen two trailers. Together with the hype, it promised to be pretty toxic and define Harry and Meghan’s relationship with the royal family for the foreseeable future.

“This sort of pre-record, known as ‘advanced fillers’ is frequently done for various news stories, obituaries etc. so journalists have instant comment in the event of breaking news. There is nothing whatever dishonourable in it.”

The Independent has reached out to Ms Arbiter and Ms Seward for comment.

Watch the video below:

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in