Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

As it happenedended1517335126

Brexit bill - as it happened: Government accused of 'cover up' as Labour vows to force release of secret papers

Follow all the latest updates from Westminster here

Ashley Cowburn
Political Correspondent
Tuesday 30 January 2018 16:31 GMT
Kier Starmer vows to force to Government to publish secret Brexit reports laying bare economic damage

Peers in the House of Lords have started the lengthy process of scrutinising Theresa May’s flagship Brexit legislation.

It comes after an influential committee in the Lords warned that the legislation – in its current form – is constitutionally unacceptable and will need to be substantially rewritten.

More than 190 members had lined up to speak during the two-day debate on the Bill’s second reading. During the first round of debates, on Tuesday, one of the best interventions came from the former Brexit minister Lord Bridges.

He challenged the Prime Minister to make clear what sort of relationship the Government wanted with the EU after Brexit, adding ministers have so far provided “no clear answers”, offering only “conflicting, confusing voices”.

He told peers he feared the Government would come up with “meaningless waffle” for its future relationship with Brussels, and that the implementation period would be “a gangplank into thin air”.

In the Commons – as Ms May headed for China on an official visit - Labour’s Shadow Brexit Secretary raised an urgent question following a leak of the Government’s Brexit impact assessments on Monday evening. The papers claimed that Britain will be worse off after leaving the bloc regardless of the deal.

Labour have now vowed to win a Commons vote to force the release of the secret analysis laying bare the economic damage from Brexit, as the affair was branded a “cover up” by one MP.


Former Cabinet minister Iain Duncan Smith said the emergence of a leaked study showing the UK economy would be worse off due to Brexit was 'suspicious'.

Responding to reports on the BuzzFeed News website that an economic impact assessment drawn up for the Government showed a negative growth outcome after EU withdrawal, he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I think the timing in this is highly suspicious in the sense that suddenly in the midst of all this conversation about the European Union we have a leaked document.

"But,I would observe that almost every single forecast coming from Government, and most of the international organisations, has been completely wrong.

"I think we should take this with a pinch of salt."

Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 08:29
Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 08:30
Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 08:30
Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 08:54

Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 08:57

This is from the Press Association on Liam Fox:

International Trade Secretary Liam Fox's warning that some Tories will "have to live with disappointment" has drawn a sharp rebuke from a leading Brexiteer.

After days of Tory turmoil over the Government's Brexit strategy, and questions raised over whether Theresa May can remain as Prime Minister, Dr Fox called for an end to the Conservative briefing war.

He told the Sun: "It doesn't help us for people to be involved in this sort of briefing they were over the weekend against individual colleagues because nothing that would happen would change the parliamentary arithmetic.

"We don't have a working majority, other than with the support of the Democratic Unionists, and we need to accept the reality of that. I know that there are always disappointed individuals but they're going to have to live with disappointment."

In response, former Tory leader Iain Duncan Smith told Dr Fox that the situation would be improved if Cabinet ministers said less and stuck to Mrs May's stance.

He told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I don't quite know what he means by disappointment. My view is leaving is the right thing to do and we will benefit from it in due course.

"I have a very simple message for my colleagues, generally: people should just calm down. The reality is this was always going to be bumpy.

"I think the best message I might send to Liam Fox and others is that, actually, if Cabinet ministers said a little less and speculated a little less about where they were, and stuck to what Theresa May has said, we might not have all of these disagreements."

Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 09:05

{"type":"article-link","data":{"title":"\u00a0\u00a0Angry Labour MPs tell Jeremy Corbyn to 'get off the fence' over single market and customs unionLabour MPs have urged Jeremy Corbyn to \u201cget off the fence\u201d and back calls for Britain to stay in the European single market and customs union after Brexit. \u00a0Figures from the Labour Campaign for the Single Market (LCSM) group called on their party leader to change tack amid \u201creal frustration\u201d among Labour members and supporters over the party\u2019s Brexit stance.","url":"
Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 09:29

Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 09:40

A new YouGov poll out this morning says 69% of Tory voters back Theresa May to remain PM. Just 18% say she should stand down. 

When all voters are took into consideration, 41% say she should remain in position while 34% say she should step down. 

YouGov last asked this question in November and May had pretty much the same level of support (42%).

Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 10:02
Ashley Cowburn30 January 2018 10:10

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in