An American couple were found dead at a luxury hotel in Mexico. Family fear they were poisoned

Abby Lutz, 28, and John Heathco, 41, were found unresponsive in their room at a luxury hotel in Baja California Sur. Loved ones believe the couple suffered carbon monoxide poisoning, Ariana Baio reports

Monday 19 June 2023 19:15 BST
Abby Lutz and John Heathco
Abby Lutz and John Heathco (Family Handout/LinkedIn)
Leer en Español

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas


Two Americans who were on vacation in Mexico were found dead in their hotel room on Tuesday, 13 June, after apparently being “poisoned” by an unknown substance.

The couple, identified as 28-year-old Abby Lutz and 41-year-old John Heathco were staying at the luxury hotel Rancho Pescadero in Baja California Sur.

Paramedics were called to the couple’s hotel room after receiving a report that they were unconscious, according to ABC News.

However, once paramedics checked, they determined Lutz and Heathco were unresponsive and did not have vital signs.

Now, Lutz’s family is speaking out, believing the two suffered from carbon monoxide poisoning.

Here’s everything we know so far.

Abby Lutz was found dead in a hotel room in Mexico with her partner John Heathco
Abby Lutz was found dead in a hotel room in Mexico with her partner John Heathco (Family handout)

What happened?

Lutz and Heathco were on vacation together in Baja California Sur, according to a statement in a GoFundMe started by one of Lutz’s family members.

The two were staying at the Rancho Pescadero, a luxury hotel and Hyatt property located in El Pescader, approximately 40 miles north of Cabo San Lucas.

Lutz and Heathco began to experience symptoms they thought were consistent with food poisoning and went to the hospital for treatment during the trip, according to Lutz’s GoFundMe.

John Heathco (pictured) was found dead in a Mexico hotel room with Abby Lutz
John Heathco (pictured) was found dead in a Mexico hotel room with Abby Lutz (LinkedIn)

The couple started feeling “much better” several days later and by Monday (12 June) were back at the hotel and communicating with their families.

Just one day later, their families received phone calls saying they had “passed away peacefully” in their hotel room in their sleep.

Paramedics in the area responded to a report of two unconscious people in the hotel and arrived around 9pm on 13 June.

The Baja California Sur attorney general’s office said in a statement that the two died of poisoning by an unknown substance and had no signs of physical violence. They said the two had been dead between 10 and 11 hours by the time they arrived.

Lutz’s family said they were told the deaths were “due to improper venting of the resort and could be carbon monoxide poisoning”.

One of the first responders, Fernando Valencia, said that he and his partner felt “dizzy” when they entered the room where Lutz and Heathco were staying.

“We went out of the room as soon as possible… I was afraid for my partner because my first thought in my mind was ‘are we going to die?’” Mr Valencia told Good Morning America in an interview.

Mr Valencia called it “one of the worst experiences.”

Henar Gil, the general manager of Rancho Pescadero said in a statement provided to The Independent: “We are truly heartbroken by this terrible tragedy. Our hearts are with the impacted families and loved ones during this unimaginable loss.”

“Local authorities are still actively investigating the situation, and the safety and security of our guests and colleagues remains a top priority, as always. We can confirm there was no evidence of violence related to this situation, and we are not aware of any threat to guests’ safety or wellbeing,” Ms Gil said.

She added “We are working to care for those who have been impacted and we are working closely with authorities as they conduct their investigation to understand the cause of death. Further inquiries should be directed to local authorities.”

US Department of State spokesperson Matthew Miller said they are “closely monitoring the investigation” into Lutz and Heathco’s deaths in a news conference on Thursday (15 June).

“We stand ready to provide any consular – any appropriate consular assistance,” Mr Miller added.

Current and former employees of the hotel have voiced concerns, alleging that the hotel knew about gas leak problems and even disabled the carbon monoxide alarms.

Ricardo Carbajal, the former night manager of Rancho Pescadero told The Los Angeles Times: “They knew there were problems with a gas leak.”

He added: “Everyone was aware of the alarms and that the detectors were off.”

Mr Carbajal, who stopped working at the luxury hotel in March, said carbon monoxide detectors went off frequently over a period of three months last year before hotel managers disabled the alarms due to noise complaints.

Current employees of the luxury hotel told The Los Angeles Times that there were complaints of a “strong smell of gas” from employees and guests but hotel managers ignored it.

“Housekeepers reported gas leaks, security reported gas leaks maintenance workers reported gas leaks,” one employee who requested to remain anonymous said.

Who are the victims?

The victims are Abby Lutz and John Heathco.

According to the GoFundMe description, they were dating at the time of their deaths.

Lutz, 28, was from Newport Beach, California but grew up in Idaho, her aunt, Karen Lutz, told The Daily Beast.

Abby Lutz
Abby Lutz (GoFundMe)

According to Karen, Lutz loved travelling and had previously visited Europe, Asia and Mexico.

“Abby was supposed to meet up with her dad this week for Father’s Day,” the GoFundMe description for Lutz says. “Abby was the most beautiful soul and we will miss her so much.”

Her family is asking for assistance in bringing her home so they give her a funeral.

Heathco owned a health supplement company in Newport Beach, according to his LinkedIn profile. It is unclear where he is from originally.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in