Chad Daybell trial: Lori Vallow’s friend confronted with subpoena outside court in cult prophet case
Chad Daybell’s trial comes one year after Lori Vallow was convicted over the murders of Tylee Ryan, JJ Vallow and Tammy Daybell
The latest headlines from our reporters across the US sent straight to your inbox each weekday
Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US
Melanie Gibb, the former friend of Lori Vallow, was served with a subpoena during a break in Chad Daybell’s triple murder trial in Boise, Idaho on Thursday.
Daybell’s defence attorney John Prior told her she had to accept to the papers. Ms Gibb was called by the prosecution to testify in the case a year after she testified at Vallow’s trial about the couple’s extreme religious beliefs.
Daybell, 55, is on trial for the murders of Vallow’s children, Tylee Ryan, 16, and JJ, seven, as well as his then-wife Tammy Daybell, who died suddenly in her sleep in October 2019. Weeks later, Daybell married Vallow.
Nine months after the children were last seen, they were found on Daybell’s property in Rexburg, Idaho.
Prosecutors say his “desire for sex, power, and money” led to their murders. Mr Prior, however, said his client was manipulated by Vallow.
Last year, Vallow was convicted in the three murders and sentenced to life in prison. Jurors heard how she, Mr Daybell and her late brother Alex Cox were fuelled, in part, by their bizarre cult beliefs.
If convicted, Mr Daybell faces either the death penalty or life in prison.
Doomsday cult, murders and children buried in a pet cemetery: The twisted case of Lori Vallow and Chad Daybell
Is Chad Daybell a doomsday cult mastermind? Trial for the murder of Lori Vallow’s children and ex-wife begins
Did a doomsday cult really drive Lori Vallow to murder her children?
Chad Daybell, Lori Vallow and Alex Cox: Key players in the ‘doomsday cult’ murder case
RECAP: Defence says Daybell was manipulated by Lori Vallow
In opening statements, Chad Daybell’s defence attorney John Prior said his client lived a normal, faith-focused life before he met Lori Vallow.
He described Vallow as a “beautiful, vivacious person” who drew Daybell into an extramarital relationship.
“What’s important are facts and evidence,” Mr Prior told the jury. “Don’t be distracted by speculation, don’t be distracted by guesses or suspicions or hunches. It all comes down to facts and evidence.”
Mr Prior also said he would present several experts in DNA, forensics and medicine who would testify that it’s impossible to determine what caused Tammy’s death and that none of Daybell’s DNA was found with the children’s bodies.
Judge extends length and scope of gag order in Chad Daybell case
Judge Steven Boyce has extended the gag order he issued in the Chad Daybell case.
It has been issued to remain in effect until the trial is concluded.
The gag order prohibits “any party to this case, including the prosecuting attorney, defense attorney, and any attorney representing a witness, victim, or victim’s family” from making writen or oral statements about the case until April 15 or after opening statements.
However, the prosecution – Fremont County Prosecuting Attorney Lindsey Blake and Madison County Prosecuting Attorney Rob Wood asked the judge on Monday to extend the motion until the end of the trial.
Ddefence attorney John Prior agreed.
All the attorneys said a gag order would “benefit the administration of a fair trial” due to media coverage.
“Investigators, law enforcement personnel, and agents for the prosecuting attorney or defense attorney, and essential court staff directly involved in the trial in this case, are prohibited from making extra judicial statements (written or oral) concerning this case between 28 March 28, 2024 and the conclusion of the trial in this case,” Judge Boyce wrote.
Where are Chad Daybell’s children?
Chad Daybell’s adult children have mostly stayed out of the spotlight in the wake of their father’s arrest in the death of their mother Tammy Daybell and Lori Vallow’s two children.
But almost all of them will testify in his death penalty case in his defence.
Daybell’s attorney John Prior says they will detail their mother’s “health struggle” before her sudden death in 2019.
Daybell had told police his wife had died suddenly in her sleep after battling an illness, but an autopsy later revealed she died of asphyxiation.
“They’re going to talk about their mother’s use of various medical treatments she would use—oils she would put on her leg, medicine, and different herbs she would take, and that their mother was suffering from a number of maladies, and she would refuse to see a doctor,”Mr Prior said during opening statements on Wednesday.
Trial continues today with first full day of testimony
The first full day of testimony in Chad Daybell’s trial will be today as Detective Hermosillo is back on the stand.
When court ended on Tuesday, the detective was explaining how the excavation of Daybell’s property progressed, and how a small body wrapped in black plastic was uncovered.
A black, round object was retrieved from the site, that Det Hermosillo described as shaped like a human head. When an incision was made into the black plastic, it revealed brown human hair according to Det Hermosillo.
It was later revealed to be JJ.
Testimony continues today at 8.30amMT/10.30amET.
ICYMI: State says Chad Daybell’s desire for ‘sex, money, power’ led to murders
Day 2 of testimony in Chad Daybell’s trial
Court will resume at 10.30 ET for the second day of testimony in Chad Daybell’s triple murder trial.
Detective Hermosillo will be back on the stand.
Watch live on Judge Steven Boyce’s YouTube channel:
Graphic evidence being shown to jurors
Jurors are now seeing graphic evidence in the case.
Judge Boyce told the court that the photos will not be shown to the public in the courtroom or on the livestream.
The jury, however, will see all the exhibits entered into evidence.
Detective recounts finding children’s remains in Daybell’s backyard
A photo is shown in court of a white piece of plastic with a little slit in the plastic that shows some brown hair.
Another photo shows the body of JJ wrapped in black plastic and duct tape, Detective Hermosillo tells the court.
"This is body composition. The body had begun to break down," the detective.
Det Hermosillo assisted the coroner in taking JJ’s body to the morgue before returning to Daybell’s house where he said they “assisted in a second burial site.”
“We knew from talking to family members that the pet cemetery had a little black dog statue next to a post.”
As the Evidence Recovery Team sifted through the dirt, Det Hermosillo says they could only work for a few minutes because the smell was so bad.
As they dug deeper, they found bone fragments and “globs of burnt flesh starting to protrude through the dirt.”
A green object was found and started to take a “roundish shape” and “at that point we saw what appeared to be the shape of a green melted bucket that appeared to have the remains of what we assumed was Tylee charred and burned inside that bucket.”
Tylee’s remains were collected and put into a body bag.
“The smell was horrendous,” the detective said.
Family of JJ Vallow, Tammy Daybell not in court for graphic evidence
Kay Woodcock, the grandmother of slain JJ Vallow, and Vicki Hoban, the aunt of Tammy Daybell, were not at the Ada County Courthouse on Thursday, according to local reporters.
The family members have been in court all week and for much of Lori Vallow’s trial last year, but their absence at today’s proceedings indicated that it was going to be a tough day.
Detective Hermosillo is currently recounting finding the children’s remains and graphic photos are being shown to the jurors, but not in court.
Who was Joshua ‘JJ' Vallow?
Joshua “JJ” Vallow was last seen on 23 September 2019. In the last known picture of him, he is wearing red pyjamas – the same ones he was wearing when his remains were found nine months later. He was seven years old.
Lori Vallow and her fourth husband Charles adopted JJ in 2014. JJ is also the biological grandson of Charles Vallow’s sister Kay Woodcock.
Ms Woodcock, who was the first witness in Vallow’s tria last year, told jurors that JJ was born with some disabilities and was diagnosed with autism.
After Charles Vallow died, Ms Woodcock said she feared Vallow no longer wanted the boy.
JJ was attending Kennedy Elementary School in Rexburg, Idaho before Vallow informed them he would not be returning and that he would be homeschooled.
In November, Ms Woodcock requested a welfare check on the boy, which sparked a nationwide search.
During Vallow’s trial, Ms Woodcock and her husband Larry sobbed as graphic evidence was shown to the court.
The grandparents were regulars at the trial and as it neared the end, Mr Woodcock could be found playing “The Party’s Over” while lined up outside the court before blaring “We Will Rock You” inside.
Both songs held a special personal meaning to him and his grandson JJ and they would often sing them together, he said.
“Today is the day,” he told journalists outside the court, dressed in a “World’s Greatest Papa” t-shirt. “I’m not the world’s greatest papa… but I hope I was the world’s greatest papa to JJ and Tylee.”
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.