Israel accused of killing 75 children during day of 'carnage' and war crimes in Gaza war

Israel disputes claims that at least 135 civilians were killed during four days of 'indiscriminate' attacks in Rafah after the capture of an IDF soldier

Lizzie Dearden
Wednesday 29 July 2015 22:20 BST
Palestinians return to what is left of their homes and businesses following the Israeli military offensive in Rafah on 1-4 August 2014
Palestinians return to what is left of their homes and businesses following the Israeli military offensive in Rafah on 1-4 August 2014

Israeli forces have been accused of carrying out war crimes during a day of “carnage” in the Gaza Strip that has been called Black Friday.

A report by Amnesty International on alleged atrocities in Rafah during last year’s conflict with Hamas claims Israeli forces killed at least 135 Palestinian civilians, including 75 children, following the capture of a soldier.

Lieutenant Hadar Goldin, 23, was with a unit searching for tunnels between Gaza and Israel when a fight started with militants and he disappeared on 1 August 2014.

Lt Hadar Goldin died in battle in the southern Gaza town of Rafah

Philip Luther, director of Amnesty International’s Middle East programme, claimed that the “relentless and massive bombardment” that ensured in residential areas of Rafah was a direct response to the capture and displayed a “shocking disregard for civilian lives”.

“They carried out a series of disproportionate or otherwise indiscriminate attacks, which they have completely failed to investigate independently,” he added.

“This report presents an urgent call for justice that must not be ignored.

“The combined analysis of hundreds of photos and videos, as well as satellite imagery and testimony from eyewitnesses, provides compelling evidence of serious violations of international humanitarian law by Israeli forces which must be investigated.”

Palestinians aid injured people on the ground following an Israeli military strike on a UN school in Rafah on 3 August 2014

The report, ‘Black Friday’: Carnage in Rafah, was compiled with Goldsmiths University’s London-based researchers Forensic Architecture and covers incidents over four days starting on 1 August, when a ceasefire broke down.

Using interviews, video footage, photographs and other evidence the researchers pieced together a timeline of events concluding that the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) “Hannibal Directive” had been enacted.

The controversial military procedure could be the subject of criminal investigation in Israel, where officials admitted it was enacted on the day of Lt Goldin’s disappearance.

Under the directive, Israeli forces can respond to the capture of a soldier with intense firepower which some analysts have claimed aim to kill the soldier rather than let them fall alive into enemy hands.

A Palestinian medic stands among bodies in a stored vegetable refrigerator in Rafah, in the southern Gaza Strip

Mr Luther said the goal was to “foil Lt Goldin’s capture at any cost…seeing entire districts of Rafah, including heavily populated residential areas, bombarded without distinction between civilians and military targets”.

In an interview with Haaretz earlier this year, Military Advocate General Maj. Gen. Danny Efroni said the “Hannibal Directive” does not target soldiers or allow violations of international law.

But Amnesty’s report found that civilians had returned to their homes in Rafah believing they were safe during an agreed ceasefire on the day when bombardment “began without warning”, with masses of people on the streets.

“Eyewitness accounts described horrifying scenes of chaos and panic as an inferno of fire from F-16 jets, drones, helicopters and artillery rained down on the streets, striking civilians on foot or in cars, as well as ambulances and other vehicles evacuating the wounded,” a spokesperson said.

One witness described the attacks that day as an attempt to pulverise Rafah’s civilians, likening the onslaught to “a machine making mincemeat out of people without mercy”.

In one of the deadliest incidents, researchers and military experts told Amnesty that two one-tonne bombs – the largest in Israel’s air force arsenal – were dropped on a single-storey building in al-Tannur in eastern Rafah.

Satellite images and photographs also appeared to show craters and other damage indicating that hospitals and ambulances were attacked repeatedly during the assault on Rafah, with one doctor describing patients and medics fleeing Abu Youssef al-Najjar hospital.

An ambulance carrying a wounded old man, woman and three children was reportedly struck by a drone-fired missile, incinerating everyone inside.

Amnesty International said the investigation revealed “compelling evidence yet of serious violations of international humanitarian law” and claimed a “cycle of impunity” continued to turn.

The group also condemned Hamas’ systematic attacks on civilian areas of Israel and the summary killing of Palestinian civilians in Gaza but maintained that Israeli authorities have failed to conduct “credible, independent and impartial investigations” into their own alleged violations.

"Victims and their families have a right to justice and reparation. And those suspected of ordering or committing war crimes must be prosecuted,” Mr Luther said.

An IDF report from 1 August claimed the 72-hour ceasefire it agreed to had been violated by Hamas and it had responded proportionately.

Palestinians carry injured people, including children, following a reported Israeli military strike on a UN school in Rafah

“Hamas used this opportunity to fire rockets into Israel and attack IDF forces in Gaza,” its website said at the time.

“During these clashes, a soldier may have been kidnapped by the terrorist organisation.”

Some of the alleged incidents documented in the report are already under investigation by the IDF’s General Staff Fact-Finding Assessment Mechanism and the findings will be used by the Military Advocate General when deciding whether to open a criminal investigation.

But a spokesperson from the Israeli Embassy called Amnesty’s report “fundamentally flawed” in its methodology, facts, analysis and conclusions, alleging that the group is biased against Israel.

Not enough focus was given to the atrocities and attacks committed by Hamas and its embedding of rocket launchers and bases in civilian environments, he said.

Palestinian militants of the Ezzedine al-Qassam Brigades, Hamas' armed wing, pictured during a parade in Gaza City last December

The spokesperson said characterising Black Friday as a direct response to the soldier’s capture ignored the other aims of Operation Protective Edge to stop rocket fire and close tunnels.

“The intensive combat that occurred in Rafah – throughout the conflict, and not just on the dates Amnesty focuses on – were no exception,” he added.

“Entire claims are based on the uncorroborated testimonies of individual Palestinians and unidentified “fieldworkers”, without considering any potential biases or coercion by Hamas authorities, or simply the fact that individuals caught in the middle of combat are limited in their capacity to know the reasons, methodologies and intentions of the fighting parties.”

The Israeli Government published its own report on the 2014 conflict which claimed that Hamas, and not its own forces, violated international law.

Smoke and flames are seen following what witnesses said were Israeli air strikes in Rafah in the southern Gaza Strip August 1, 2014.

“In contrast to Amnesty’s claims, the IDF – as the military of a democratic state committed to the rule of law – conducts all its operations in accordance with international law,” the spokesperson said.

“Where allegations of misconduct arise, the IDF maintains a robust, effective and thorough mechanism for addressing them… once again Amnesty has shown its compulsive obsessiveness towards Israel, by rehashing already existing claims and complaints into a smoke and mirrors website.”

More than 1,400 Palestinian civilians were killed in the 50 day war, a third of them children, according to a UN report that found "possible war crimes" on both sides.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies


Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in