Valentine's Day 2016: 17 best chocolates

Treat them to something sweet with a tried and tested favourite

Chocolates have become as synonymous with Valentine’s Day as flowers. Read on to find out which ones we think are the best of the bunch for this year. Fear not if your pockets aren’t deep as there are plenty of budget options, as well as high-end decadence for those with more cash to splash.

1. ChoconChoc Perfect Match Chocolates: £6.99, ChoconChoc 


This witty take on love-themed chocolates make for a more unusual Valentine's Day offering . Hand-made in Somerset using creamy white Belgian chocolate, these treats taste fabulous. You’ll be relieved to know they are substantially bigger than usual matches – around five times as long and 20 times as thick. The words “Perfect Match” are etched on the side.

Buy now

2. Godiva Valentine’s Round Gift Box: £20, Godiva


Godiva’s indulgent boxes from its Coupes d’Amour collection are hand-made in Brussels. The so-called “cups of love” come in five melt-in-the-mouth flavours including banana, strawberry, pistachio, caramel café and intense chocolate.

Buy now

3. Hotel Chocolat Straight from the Heart: £39, Hotel Chocolat 


Hotel Chocolat has an impressive range of Valentine’s chocolates for all budgets, but our favourite is this array of 35 chocolates and truffles, many of them heart-shaped and with romantic flavour combinations, such as Pink Champagne and Caramel Gianduja. 

Buy now

5. The Chocolate Society Gjanduja Honeycomb Hearts: £29.99, Selfridges


Filled with delicious milk chocolate, hazelnut gjanduja and shards of hand-made honeycomb, this set of 15 beautifully presented red hearts is ideal for people who like a bit of crunch in their chocolate. They are definitely not to be scoffed and instead savoured in appreciative silence. 

Buy now

6. Cocoapod Personalised Chocolate Squares: £3.50, Not on the High Street


Two of these four chocolates can be personalised with initials, while the remaining two feature one of the Kent-based company’s own designs, such as small hearts. The letter squares are hand-made from Belgian chocolate and the pattern squares are either strawberry and orange or plain, milk or white.

Buy now

7. Rococo Venus Nipples and Lips: £14.95, Rococo


The name is supposed to sound saucy, although we think they sound a bit like the snacks Graham Chapman was selling in the People’s Front of Judea scene in Monty Python’s The Life of Brian. Nevertheless, the four handmade red lips (dark chocolate covered in hand-painted white chocolate) and six venus nipples (coffee truffles covered in white chocolate, with a coffee bean) are astonishingly tasty and look extra-special. .

Buy now

8. Harrods Chocolate Love Bears: £9.95, Harrods


We reckon it will be love at first bite with these sweet chocolate bears. Made from rich and smooth Belgian milk chocolate, their hearts are painted – you guessed it – red, and they all come in a see-through box that’s gift wrapped with a neat red ribbon.

Buy now

9. M&S Perfect Pairs Heart Collection: £15, Marks & Spencer


M&S have shaken things up a bit with these milk, white and dark truffles, pairing them with flavours such as strawberry and balsamic, truffle and sea salt and caramel and passion fruit. The result is a box of indulgent chocs that you may well want to keep all to yourself.

Buy in-store

10. Montezuma’s Valentine’s Hamper: £19.99, Montezuma's


This brand excels in making handmade chocolate with robust and often quirky flavours. We love its Valentine’s hamper, which contains a milk chocolate and butterscotch heart, salted caramel heart truffles, a milk chocolate bar with caramelised sesame and sunflower seeds, and – our favourite – a white chocolate bar with lemon and sour cherry.

Buy now

11. Divine Dark Chocolate Hearts: £1.12, Waitrose


These mini dark chocolate love hearts from this partly farmer-owned company are individually foil-wrapped and have just the right balance of sweet and bitter. They’re suitable for vegetarians and are palm oil free, as well as being Fairtrade. Not keen on dark chocolate? They’re also available in milk chocolate or white chocolate with strawberry. 

Buy now

12. Artisan du Chocolat Sweetheart Tin: £9.99, Artisan du Chocolat


This brand makes exceptionally fresh chocolates that taste wonderful. This charming tin offers a small collection of some of their best ever flavours, including our favourite, the salted caramel, and the more unusual cherry and cardamom coulis.

Buy now

13. Chococo Love Box: from £13.95, Chococo


This Dorset-based family firm makes some of the freshest chocolates in the UK, with no additives or preservatives, and you can taste the difference immediately. This box, available in two sizes, contains the likes of Arbequina olive oil and sea salt, passion fruit, sakura tea and champagne and strawberry. Good news for couples: there is two of everything.

Buy now

14. Fifth Dimension Valentine’s Box: £17, Fifth Dimensions


Relatively new to the chocolate scene, this British chocolatier has quickly gained an excellent reputation, most recently winning at the International Chocolate Awards. This box includes 12 handmade treats with unique flavours, such as peanut and raspberry. It’s as good as it gets for lovers of fine chocolates made from single origin cocoa.

Buy now

15. Fortnum & Mason Personalised Chocolates: from £30, Fortnum & Mason


The Fortnum’s name is the first clue that these chocolates are none too shabby. Straight from its world-renowned chocolate counter, flavours include vanilla fudge, sea-salted caramel truffles and pralines, all of which are melt-in-the-mouth. There are three sizes available, and all of them can be personalised with initials.

Buy now

16. Prestat Heart Assortment: from £7, Prestat


Prestat, with its longstanding Royal Warrant, has come up trumps this year with a range of four heart-shaped, pink chocolate boxes. Among the flavours are passion fruit fondant, rice crisp nougat, ginger and saffron fudge and rose crème. If it’s good enough for the Queen…

Buy now

17. Carluccio’s Rose Di Cioccolato e Prosecco: £55, Carluccio's 


Italians know a thing or two about love and romance, so it should come as no surprise that Carluccio’s has come up with this fabulous box containing the ultimate symbol of love – red roses – the heads of which are actually solid milk chocolates made by Caffarel, the age-old Italian confectioner based in Piedmont. There’s a bottle of top-notch, delicate fizz to wash them down with, too.

Buy now


We think you’ll be hard pushed to find any chocolate lover who would be disappointed with Hotel Chocolat’s Straight from the Heart Box, and it gets our overriding vote for being the best of our more extravagant suggestions. For a smaller token of love, ChoconChoc’s Perfect Match Chocolates are both fun and romantic.

IndyBest product reviews are unbiased, independent advice you can trust. On some occasions, we earn revenue if you click the links and buy the products, but we never allow this to bias our coverage. The reviews are compiled through a mix of expert opinion and real-world testing