Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

Apple iPad pro vs iPad air: Which tablet comes out on top?

We discover if the new top-of-the-range model is worth the investment

David Phelan
Friday 21 May 2021 12:38 BST
The pro’s power is unquestionable – but do you really need it?
The pro’s power is unquestionable – but do you really need it? (The Independent)

The brand new Apple tablet, the iPad pro, has just gone on sale. It offers significant upgrades over last year’s model, but it’s also an interesting contrast with the company’s next model down, the iPad air. If you’re looking for a new tablet, here’s how to choose between them.

iPad pro vs iPad air: The similarities

The design language is strikingly similar: flat edges, unlike earlier iPads, with sharp sides and curved corners. Both have a subtle panel on the right edge, to which the versatile Apple Pencil stylus clips to charge. This optional accessory is the second-generation Pencil, by the way, which has added features.

Both tablets also work with another add-on, the magic keyboard folio, which wraps around the tablet and offers a successful way to type on the iPad. While the operating system is different from a Mac or PC, a tablet plus a keyboard makes a great alternative to a laptop.

Both tablets have touchscreens with multi-touch capabilities, and both the iPadOS, with its million-plus apps designed specifically for iPad-sized screens.

Oh, and the materials are the same across both, with an aluminium casing and glass display. The display is pretty much edge-to-edge: there’s no Touch ID button on the front, as with earlier versions of the tablets.

Read more:

All iPads come in two versions, wifi only or wifi plus cellular, which has a sim card slot so you can connect to the internet without needing to be in range of wi-fi.

There’s a hefty extra charge for the cellular versions, especially since you can also access the internet on your iPad by using the network on a nearby iPhone. You’ll be limited to the speed of connection of the phone, in that case. Only the iPhone 12, iPhone 12 mini, iPhone 12 pro and iPhone 12 pro max are 5G iPhones, and the iPad pro is the only 5G tablet from Apple.

Finally, unlike the iPhone, Apple still puts a charging plug and cable in the box with its tablets, on the basis that while everyone has an old phone charger knocking around, tablet proliferation is much less pronounced and so suitable chargers are not as ubiquitous. Also, a tablet needs a more powerful charger.

You can trust our independent reviews. We may earn commission from some of the retailers, but we never allow this to influence selections, which are formed from real-world testing and expert advice. This revenue helps to fund journalism across The Independent.

Apple iPad pro 2021

apple-ipad-pro-2021.jpg

Buy now £749, Apple.com

Screen: 11in LCD or 12.9in liquid retina XDR

Security system: Face ID

Processor: Apple M1

Connectivity: USB-C Thunderbolt

Compatibility: Apple Pencil 2nd generation, magic keyboard

Storage: 128GB, 256GB, 512GB, 1TB or 2TB

Colours: Space grey or silver

Price: 11in from £749 with wifi or from £899 with wifi and cellular; 12.9in from £999 with wifi, from £1,149 with wifi and cellular

The new iPad is not only the fastest and most powerful tablet you’ll come across, it also outdoes most laptops – even high-end ones. The pro has the best of everything Apple makes, hence the premium pricing.

For a start, there’s the M1 processor which is also found in the Apple MacBook pro: putting a top-notch PC performance chip in a tablet is unheard of. The iPad air is also really fast, thanks to its A14 Bionic chip also found in the latest iPhones, but the increase in power on the iPad pro is a real step-change. That said, much of the time you may not notice the difference, as the air is fast enough for most situations. It’s when you’re running really power-hungry applications that the pro comes into its own. Apps such as those that provide video editing, where the iPad pro can work with multiple super-high-resolution video files simultaneously with no delay or slowdown, are particularly impressive.

One place where you will notice the difference is the display. LCD screens usually have just one backlight, occasionally a few more than that. This means that black shades are rarely blacker than dark grey, because the wash of the backlight is visible. Apple’s displays have always been good at disguising this, but the new liquid retina XDR screen here – on the 12.9in iPad pro only – is phenomenal.

That’s because it has more than 10,000 tiny backlights using a technology called miniLED. These LEDs can be controlled as 2,500 locally dimmed zones. This means the dark areas of the screen are truly deep blacks, so those black bars when you’re watching a letterboxed movie disappear altogether, while colours are bright and punchy. It also offers amazing brightness, which helps the screen look even more eye popping.

The 11in model has the same screen as last year’s iPad pro, that is, a highly effective LCD screen. It still outdoes the display on the iPad air in several ways. First, it’s that little bit bigger, measuring 11in instead of the air’s 10.9in. It also has “ProMotion”, which means it dynamically adjusts the refresh rate of the screen as needed. This means scrolling through menus, screens or anything else looks especially smooth, for instance, but a lower refresh rate will be implemented when it’s not needed, saving battery life.

The liquid retina XDR display is the only difference between the 11in and 12.9in iPad pros, apart from the physical size difference and price tag.

Then there’s Face ID, the super secure and intimate way to unlock your device just by looking at it, which the air doesn’t have. It also has even thinner bezels around the display than other tablets, which explains why the pro 11in screen fits exactly the same space as the air with its 10.9in one. Still, the air, as we’ll see below, has a great alternative to Face ID.

The iPad pro upgrades the connectivity of the tablet. Both the air and pro have a USB-C connector, but on the pro models it’s a Thunderbolt connection, which is faster. This means that if you’re a professional photographer, for instance, you can transfer big photographic files to or from the tablet more quickly.

We’ve all been doing more video-conferencing than we would have liked recently, and Apple is at least aiming to make this a more enjoyable experience. It’s replaced the wide-angle lens on the front of the iPad pro with an ultra-wide one. This works with the M1 processor in a feature called “centre stage”. The camera zooms in on you, wherever in the frame you are, and if you move around the room it pans intelligently to ensure you stay the centre of attention.

Then there’s 5G. This is the first 5G-capable tablet, assuming you buy the wifi plus cellular option. It means that not only do you have the versatility to connect to the internet away from a wifi network, but if it’s a strong 5G signal, it’ll be extremely fast, and more secure than some wifi. We tested the iPad pro using the EE network and the results, in London, ranged from decent to phenomenally fast.

There are two rear cameras on the iPad pro. Though a large, flat slab of glass and aluminium does not make for an ergonomic camera, the large display does make for a great viewfinder.

There’s also a LiDAR scanner, which helps improve photography by grabbing depth information very quickly. LiDAR is also used in augmented reality apps, and on the iPad pro an updated app called Clips lets you create videos with impressive special effects.

  1. £749 from Apple.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

Apple iPad air 2020

apple-ipad-air-2021.jpg

Buy now £579, Apple.com

Screen: 10.9in LCD

Security system: Touch ID

Processor: A14 Bionic

Connectivity: USB-C

Compatibility: Apple Pencil 2nd generation, magic keyboard

Storage: 64GB or 256GB

Colours: Space grey, silver, rose gold or green sky blue

Price: From £579 with wifi; from £709 with wifi and cellular

The iPad air looks like a very slightly thicker version of the iPad pro 11in, though with wider bezels around the 10.9in display. But where the pro has Face ID thanks to extra sensors next to the front-facing camera, the iPad air uses Touch ID, the fingerprint sensor which has been on Apple tablets since the iPad air 2 in 2014.

Until now, it’s been on the front of the tablet, below the display. This model, which is the fourth-generation iPad air, introduces a new version that sits in the power button on the top edge. It works amazingly: it’s fast and reliable. In convenience terms it’s even better than Face ID, though in security terms, Face ID trumps it.

In almost every respect, the iPad pro components outdo those of the air, but that doesn’t mean this is a second-class tablet. The A14 Bionic processor is identical to the one in the iPhone 12 series that’s very fast indeed.

The air only comes in two storage options, the larger of which is only an eighth of the maximum option on the iPad pro. Still, that will be enough for most people.

There’s only one camera on the iPad air, a 12MP wide lens, and there’s no LiDAR scanner. Even so, photographs taken on the air are very good.

Like the iPad pro, the air is compatible with the magic keyboard, or indeed a more affordable smart keyboard folio from Apple. The Apple Pencil accessory also works well, attaching magnetically to the side of the tablet for safekeeping.

The display is great: unless it’s side-by-side with the iPad pro, you won’t feel short-changed. It’s not as bright as the pro, and lacks the super-high maximum brightness of the 12.9in iPad pro, but it’s the same resolution and includes features like the “true tone” display which monitors the colour temperature of your surroundings and adjusts the output accordingly, so a white page still looks white, for instance.

Battery life is the same as the pro – in fact, an iPad pro 12.9 user who watches a lot of demanding content on the miniLED screen may find their battery burns a little faster than it does on the air.

  1. £579 from Apple.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

The verdict: Apple iPad pro vs Apple iPad air

Both of these tablets are outstanding, from the immaculate build quality to the intuitive Apple operating system. The display, processor, connectivity, cameras – actually, just about everything – are better on the iPad pro, which has the best components and features Apple has ever put in a tablet.

And there’s the super-fast 5G option in the wifi plus cellular models, something the air can’t match, instead offering a 4G capability.

There’s no doubt, the iPad pro beats the iPad air hands-down. Except, for most people most of the time, some of those benefits may not be worth the extra cost.

Sure, the iPad pro 12.9in display is astonishingly good, unlike any other tablet or laptop, but the iPad air screen is still gorgeous, immersive and effective.

There is no tablet, and few laptops, that come close to the performance of the M1 chip in the iPad pro. But the iPad air is no slouch so, unless you have advanced professional needs, it will be more than fast enough.

The air is exceptional value, looks glorious in its five different colour options, and is a solid performer. The iPad pro does everything that bit better, is especially fast and responsive and has the option of dazzlingly good screen technology.

So, look at it like this: you can’t go wrong either way.

Voucher codes

For the latest discounts on tablets and other tech offers, try the below links:

Still not sure which tablet is right for you? Read our comprehensive guide to the best tablets for 2021

Looking for a smaller tablet? Read our review of the Apple iPad mini 2021

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in