Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

comment

With Ken Clarke’s warning ringing in our ears, we must ask: When does democracy turn into dictatorship?

The point of parliament is more than just having an election every four or five years and allowing a government to do what the hell it likes, writes Sean O’Grady

Tuesday 30 January 2024 17:22 GMT
Comments
Lord Clarke warned that overturning a Supreme Court ruling could see the UK slipping into an ‘elected dictatorship’
Lord Clarke warned that overturning a Supreme Court ruling could see the UK slipping into an ‘elected dictatorship’ (Parliament TV)

At a time when Donald Trump and Joe Biden are giving old age a bad name, it is refreshing to see Ken Clarke, now ensconced in the House of Lords at the age of 83, reminding us that there is such a thing as an elder statesman – and you get to be one by talking common sense.

Always robust and lively, he’s not quite as mobile as he was – but that acute political mind is as keen as ever. He tells it like it is. He also tells the government that it is making a fool of itself over the Rwanda plan and is threatening grievous bodily harm on our poor old battered constitution. He got to the heart of the matter: warning that overturning a Supreme Court ruling could see the UK slipping into an “elected dictatorship”.

He has heard, as we all have, quite enough self-serving nonsense about the “sovereignty of parliament” and the “will of the people”. The doctrine of parliamentary sovereignty is a complicated one – and obviously up for debate – but it should never be the case that a prime minister with a majority in the Commons (normally achieved on a minority of the vote) can do what he or she wishes. Using the argument that the Commons is “sovereign” and it is therefore the “will of the people” doesn’t wash.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in