Brooklyn shooting update: Frank James ordered to be held behind bars in first federal court appearance
James, 62, is charged with terrorism on a mass transportation system over Tuesday’s Brooklyn subway attack
The latest headlines from our reporters across the US sent straight to your inbox each weekday
Your briefing on the latest headlines from across the US
Suspected terrorist Frank James appeared in Brooklyn federal court for the first time on Thursday where a judge ordered him to be held behind bars until his trial and his lawyers requested he undergo a psychological exam.
Mr James, 62, is charged with terrorism on a mass transportation system over Tuesday’s Brooklyn subway attack where he allegedly shot 10 people before going on the run for 30 hours.
The suspect was finally arrested in Manhattan’s East Village on Wednesday afternoon when he called CrimeStoppers himself to tell police he was at a nearby McDonald’s.
Officers descended on the fast food joint to find him gone, before taking him into custody nearby along St. Mark’s Place and First Avenue.
Mr James is accused of injuring around 30 people in Tuesday morning’s rush hour attack in Sunset Park.
The gunman donned a gas mask on a packed N train travelling to Manhattan and opened a gas canister, before opening fire as the train travelled into 36 Street station.
His motive remains unclear but disturbing YouTube videos show Mr James ranting about Mayor Eric Adams, the subway system and NYC’s mental health system.
Brooklyn shooting focuses attention on controversial Eric Adams safety plans
The Brooklyn subway shooting, the latest in a string of high-profile violent incidents in New York City, is focusing scrunity on mayor Eric Adams’s public safety—and his many controversial plans for the sprawling, deeply unequal metropolis he governs.
At the beginning of the year, the mayor announced plans to bring back a controversial plainclothes police unit to combat gun violence, even though the squad was previously criticised for racial profiling and brutal tactics.
NYC mayor bringing back controversial NYPD unit after wave of killings
Plainclothes officers have been involved in some of New York’s most infamous cases of police violence, and have been accused of racial profiling
Others have noted that on the mayor has directed a large portions of police resources towards clearing out homeless encampments, including one such camp that was swept the day before the shooting.
Critics have argued this policy does little to help those impacted and further destabilises life for the unhoused.
NYC planning to remove homeless encampments from streets
New York City officials are planning to remove makeshift shelters set up by homeless people on city streets, mirroring similar efforts in other liberal metropolises that had previously tolerated the encampments
ICYMI: Frank James denied bail in Brooklyn subway terror case
The man accused of bringing terror to the New York City transport system has been ordered to be held without bail in custody.
Frank James, 62, made a brief appearance at a federal courthouse in Brooklyn on Thursday, just under 24 hours after he was arrested in Manhattan’s East Village.
Assistant US Attorney Sara K. Winik told the court that Mr James had caused panic to New Yorkers’ morning commute in a way not seen since 9/11.
“The defendant terrifyingly opened fire on passengers on a crowded subway train, interrupting their morning commute in a way the city hasn’t seen in more than 20 years.”
Bevan Hurley has the story.
Frank James ordered held in first for attack on New York ‘not seen since 9/11’
Frank James, 62, is accused of firing 33 shots into a crowded subway car
Donald Trump Jr says security cameras failed in Brooklyn shooting because of ‘leftist narrative'
Donald Trump Jr has spent the last few days creating an elaborate conspiracy theory that surveilance cameras malfunctioned during the hunt for accused Brooklyn subway shooter Frank James because of the “leftist narrative.”
“Why do the security cameras never seem to work when the reality of the crime isn’t good for the leftist narrative???” he wrote on Twitter.
Instead, the former president’s son has valorised the New York Police Department for their work on the case.
“Great work NYPD,” he added. “Despite the constant attacks from the leftist leaders of New York you guys still get it done… unlike the FBI leadership who seem far more interested in creating crimes and letting the actual bad guys go.”
In reality, the cameras were already failing two days before the shooting, a problem that New York City Transit workers flagged about the security feeds, which are monitored by the NYPD.
Conservative commentators have been arguing that Mr James, whose YouTube channel at times contains videos with ideas about Black nationalism, has been getting soft treatment in the media and courts compared to right-wing suspects.
In fact, the 62-year-old has been charged with the same kind of penalties as other terrorists who target mass transit.
Brooklyn subway shooting isn’t first shocking attack in transit system
In January, businesswoman Michelle Alyssa Go was pushed onto the subway tracks by a homeless man at the busy Times Square subway, which regularly has a large police presence.
Commentators are arguing the incident is a reminder that amid calls to send even more police into the subway system, their deployment doesn’t inherently mean a safer system.
Instead, such plans for the NYPD, which already has an astounding $10.4 billion budget, could lead to further harassment of low-income people like turnstile-jumpers and street vendors by police.
“The Brooklyn shooting is a terrifying incident that could have been a true tragedy. It’s good that the suspect has been apprehended,” MSNBC Opinion Columnist Hayes Brown recently argued. “But the most likely outcome is that, yet again, America’s cities will be basing their anti-crime policy on what’s easiest for their leaders, not what’s best for their residents.”
How did Frank James buy a gun?
Frank James, the suspected Brooklyn subway shooter, had a lengthy criminal record, being arrested numerous times as he bounced between Newark, Philadelphia, and other cities across the US.
But the charges were never serious enough to earn him a felony, which would’ve stopped him from buying a gun, according to police.
ICYMI: #Thankyouzack, the unexpected hero of the Brooklyn subway shooting
A 21-year-old Syrian man, who played a role in the capture of the suspected Brooklyn subway shooter on Wednesday, won hearts after he described how he saw Frank James through one of the security cameras and followed him.
Zack Tahhan, who moved from Syria to the US five years ago, recognised the alleged shooter while he was fixing a camera outside a convenience store in the East Village in Manhattan.
He was hailed as a hero — with #Thankyouzack trending on Twitter — after he followed the man and alerted police officers.
Read more in Stuti Mishra’s piece.
Another police story that deserves your attention
Police in Grand Rapids, Michigan have released several videos showing a police officer’s interaction with Patrick Lyoya moments before the officer fatally shot him earlier this month.
The video shows the officer – a seven-year veteran who has not been named – struggling to arrest Lyoya, a 26-year-old Black man, before holding him to the ground and fatally shooting him on 4 April.
Gustaf Kilander and Alex Woodward have the details on the controversial killing.
Everything we know about police killing of Patrick Lyoya
‘He arrived in the United States as a refugee with his family fleeing violence. He had his whole life ahead of him,’ governor says
How bystanders—and Frank James himself—helped capture Brooklyn shooting suspect
The tip that led to the arrest of the Brooklyn subway shooting suspect Frank James was called in by Mr James himself.
Law enforcement officials said that Mr James, 62, called Crime Stoppers and gave his location before his arrest in New York’s East Village neighbourhood on Wednesday.
Police said at an earlier press conference that Mr James was tipped to be at a McDonald’s restaurant on 6th Street and 1st Avenue. He was found around the corner and arrested without incident.
Justin Vallejo has more.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.