The Independent’s journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission.

9 best notebooks for ideas, to-do lists and journaling

Ditch the notes on your phone and go old-school with one of these pads

Martha Alexander
Monday 28 June 2021 15:45
<p>A new notebook is a symbol of potential, of beginnings, or promises and pledges</p>

A new notebook is a symbol of potential, of beginnings, or promises and pledges

The joy of a brand-new notebook cannot be overstated: it stands for so much more than a collection of plain pages. A new notebook is a symbol of potential, of beginnings, or promises and pledges. It is a commitment to a tidy desk, to fresh ideas, a lighter handbag or less screen-time.

In a digital age, it’s kind of wonderful that fresh stationery is still so inspiring – with notebooks especially respected. What makes a great notebook depends, firstly, on what you want to use it for.

Are you a prolific list maker or more of a visually-led person who would like space to draw as well as write? Will you be writing the start of a novel or song lyrics? Are you looking for a date-less diary or a space to journal? Will your notebook live on your desk or need to be diminutive enough to slip into an inside pocket?

The first thing to think about is how easy a notebook is to use. If you can’t write comfortably or if the paper is poor quality – either repelling ink or letting it bleed heavily – your experience is going to be negative. We want to see good quality paper that allows ink to flow easily – neither to shiny nor too mealy. Do you always want lined paper or the freedom of plain pages?

You also need to think aesthetically – and we think looks do matter here. This is an item that will live on your desk, you might take to meetings or have in your handbag. Whether you want a bold statement or subtle elegance, your notebook will say something about you.

Read more:

Many companies now offer personalisation – which is especially lovely when gifting. There are also a variety of eco considerations to be made – there are sustainable and vegan options out there.

As always, we’ve looked at a range of prices – from over £80 to under £10 so that all budgets and occasions are catered for.

You can trust our independent reviews. We may earn commission from some of the retailers, but we never allow this to influence selections, which are formed from real-world and expert advice. This revenue helps us to fund journalism across The Independent.

The best notebooks 2021:

  • Best overall – Hoxton A notebook for bad ideas: £15,
  • Best for writing reams and reams – Katie Leamon Lay flat notebook: £21.95,
  • Best for all-out luxury – Smythson Chelsea notebook: £85,
  • Best for escapism – Papier Mirage foiled notebook: £24.99,
  • Best for supporting women – Sasha compton large journal: £65,
  • Best for travelling light – Lava notebook: £6.50,
  • Best for design nerds – Moo Hardcover notebook: £14.99,
  • Best for understated elegance – Dot grid notebook: £28,
  • Best vegan leather – Yop and Tom Moon and stars lined journal: £14.99,

Hoxton Mini Press a notebook for bad ideas

Best: Overall

There are endless quotes about bad ideas attributed to brilliant people and they all essentially say “in order to have good ideas you must first have bad ones”. This is the thinking behind this notebook (20 x 14cm). Its creators describe it as a “perfect notebook in which to risk imperfection”. And it really is pretty perfect as both an object and a tool.

Inside the wrapping paper – a hand-drawn map of East London – you’ve got a hardback and beautifully bound notebook. Once you open the notebook you realise it can lie flat for maximum writing comfort. There are 160 pages of acid-free ivory paper ready for your failures and the subsequent successes. You can choose lined or plain.

We loved using this – the name gave us permission to seize the moment and stop trying to write neat, perfect ideas.

Katie Leamon lay flat notebook

Best: For writing reams and reams

Ever been irritated by how notebooks flip flop all over the place when you are in the middle of writing out your brainchildren? This flat lay notebook (14.8 x 21cm) is the answer. It opens and as its name suggests, lays flat on the table so you can write in comfort and with ease. After you’ve used this you will probably ask why all notebooks aren’t made like this. With a soft cover, this is fairly lightweight which is welcome for those frequently on the move. Other colourways are available but we thought this was the chicest.

Smythson Chelsea notebook

Best: For all-out luxury

Yes, yes, we know that’s a lot of money for a notebook but this (11.2 x 16.7cm) is arguably the smartest, most luxurious of its kind. The leather exterior is as soft as you’d expect lambskin to be and the 144 feather-light pale blue pages are tipped with gilt. The pages are lined and perhaps best suited to those with diminutive handwriting. Those with supersized cursive might find this tough to navigate.

There are plenty of colours to choose from but the scarlet makes the biggest statement. You can also have it embossed in gold – another little luxury that will seem essential after using this! The only drawback as far as we can see is that it’s almost too beautiful to be used.

Papier mirage foiled notebook

Best: For escapism

There are 96 leaves of 85gsm paper – it feels thick and luxurious while still being practical and “everyday”. We love that it can be personalised on the front and the spine is very pretty – lovely if you’re someone who likes to file your notebooks on a shelf.

This notebook (15.3 x 21.5 cm) is part of a gorgeous new collection from Papier – all evoking the heat and brightness of the summer months. We love how the palm trees and mosaic detailing speaks to faraway lands and holidays, something most of us could all do with.

Noble Macmillan x Sasha Compton large journal

Best: For supporting women

This leather notebook (15.4 x 21.9 cm) is part of a collaboration between Noble Macmillan and artist Sasha Compton. It features the latter’s Female Dancer illustration on the cover and her “Every pair is perfect” design on the inside covers. The exterior is made of a calfskin leather – smooth to the touch and unbelievably soft while inside are 80 pages of unlined cream pages that are thick and, we thought, worked beautifully with a fountain pen.

If you’re not tickled pink by this shade, there is a navy version, but it’s smaller. Aside from being easy on the eye and a joy to write in, it’s also a force for good beyond storing our lists, ideas and memories: fifteen per cent of the profits from each book goes to the charity, Smart Works which provides high-quality interview clothes and interview training to unemployed women in need.

The Completist lava notebook

Best: For travelling light

This is a cute little book (4.8 x 21cm) with a bright, jolly cover (and the inside cover is a treat for eyes too – a deep green block) of 300gsm card with white wire binding for the spine. What we loved – aside from the price – was how you can choose the interior detailing: line or grid? There are 44 pages of TCF (total chlorine-free) paper and we loved the slimness. It means you can slip it easily between laptop and novel in your rucksack and it weighs next to nothing. A bargain that looks expensive – result!

Moo hardcover notebook

Best: For design nerds

This hardback cloth-bound notebook (13 x 20.7cm) comes in its own hard case – a beautiful, sculptural object that any design buffs will go wild for. There are loads more features to get stationery junkies hot under the collar – the Swiss binding to ensure the pages don’t pop up all the time. We opted for the grey version but there are others available. You can choose whether the paper inside has lines or dots on it but either way it’s delicious. There is also a section of 16 pages of coloured paper running through the middle of the book (ours were green).

Mark & Fold dot grid notebook

Best: For understated elegance

Made sustainably in Scotland, this soft-cover notebook sings with understated quality. The cover is 300gsm and made from used coffee cups, giving it stellar eco credentials. It offers 128 pages of 5mm “dot grid” paper, which makes it versatile – ideal for people whose work entails writing, sketching, bulleting and doodling.

It’s simple and elegant with a thread-sewn seam and lay flat design for the spine ensuring easy writing. If dots aren’t what you’re after there are lined versions and plain versions but all are easy to write in, even with thick ink. We plumped for a mustard shade for the cover – but if you want something more discreet there are other hues to choose from.

Yop & Tom moon and stars lined journal

Best: Vegan leather

We love the weightiness of the book – it feels substantial and important. And we always love a notebook with a strap to keep it closed – so we were cheered to see one on this vegan leather-covered hardback journal (A5). It feels like “real” leather and encases 180 lined pages of crisp white paper. We were also especially pleased to find that the vegan leather is stain resistant, particularly when we spilt a double espresso on it. Wiped off without a trace! The flat lay design is great for comfort and it’s always handy to have an inbuilt envelope for receipts, stamps and postcards.

The verdict: Notebooks

We’re in love with the Hoxton Mini Press a notebook for bad ideas – it’s inspiring, beautiful, practical and doesn’t cost the world. It’s a really thoughtful gift – especially if you’re giving it to yourself at the start of a new creative project.

The Smythson chelsea notebook is in another league when it comes to luxury, but the price tag reflects that. While at the other end of the spectrum The Completist’s lava notebook offers a super-affordable journal that is easy on the eye, a delight to use and feather-light.

Voucher codes

For the latest offers on stationery, try the links below:

Discover some great authors and books you’ll love in the Women’s Prize for Fiction shortlist 2021

IndyBest product reviews are unbiased, independent advice you can trust. On some occasions, we earn revenue if you click the links and buy the products, but we never allow this to bias our coverage. The reviews are compiled through a mix of expert opinion and real-world testing.

Register for free to continue reading

Registration is a free and easy way to support our truly independent journalism

By registering, you will also enjoy limited access to Premium articles, exclusive newsletters, commenting, and virtual events with our leading journalists

Please enter a valid email
Please enter a valid email
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
Must be at least 6 characters, include an upper and lower case character and a number
Please enter your first name
Special characters aren’t allowed
Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters
Please enter your last name
Special characters aren’t allowed
Please enter a name between 1 and 40 characters
You must be over 18 years old to register
You must be over 18 years old to register
You can opt-out at any time by signing in to your account to manage your preferences. Each email has a link to unsubscribe.

Already have an account? sign in

By clicking ‘Register’ you confirm that your data has been entered correctly and you have read and agree to our Terms of use, Cookie policy and Privacy notice.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy policy and Terms of service apply.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in