The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

My picky-eater dog tried Aldi’s dog ice cream – here’s what we thought

We put the cold dog-friendly dessert to the test, but the jury’s out on whether our pooch actually enjoyed it

Alex Lee
Thursday 23 June 2022 13:48 BST
Is Aldi’s dog ice cream worth the buy?
Is Aldi’s dog ice cream worth the buy? (The Independent)

Support truly
independent journalism

Our mission is to deliver unbiased, fact-based reporting that holds power to account and exposes the truth.

Whether $5 or $50, every contribution counts.

Support us to deliver journalism without an agenda.

Louise Thomas

Louise Thomas


Everyone loves the summer. Get some shorts on, lather on some sunscreen and flip-flop your way to the beach. But for my dog Gatsby? All hairy and furry and panty, well, he really couldn’t hate the blazing heat any more.

While I’ve got my pick of ice creams to slurp on, rum and raisin, cookies and cream, mango and passionfruit, you name it – my woolly friend is always sat there staring at me with his tongue lolling out of his mouth, making do with boring bowls of water and ice cubes. Until now, that is.

Last week, Aldi became the first UK supermarket to launch ice cream for dogs. The retailer released two dog-friendly and plant-based flavours – pea and vanilla and apple and carrot, just in time for the hot weather.

But there was a snag. Gatsby is a meathead, he’s a picky eater. He turns his nose up at treats other dogs would devour in one second flat and shifts vegetables around with his snout so he can get to the good stuff. If you own a dog like this, you know that a treat for some dogs might not be a treat for yours.

So even if he got some ice cream of his own, would he actually eat it? If he did, would he enjoy it? And most of all, would it cool him down? I got my hands on Aldi’s Beechdean doggy ice cream, and my dog and I put it to the test.

Read more:

How we tested

It’s pretty simple. I scooped up some ice cream out of the tiny tub, scrutinised how it looked, plopped it into my fussy-eater dog’s bowl and watched as he licked (or didn’t lick) it. Did he finish it all? How quickly did he scarf it down? Did he prefer one flavour over the other? Had he stopped panting from the heat? And of course, was his lolling tongue gone? Here’s what we made of this cool treat.

Aldi beechdean doggy ice cream: £2.99, – available in-store only

(Alex Lee/The Independent)

Aldi’s doggy ice cream, manufactured by Beechdean, comes in a box of four. You get two 110ml tubs of pea and vanilla and two 110ml tubs of apple and carrot in each. They’re both coconut based and either have chunks of carrot or peas inside each scoop, so they are a pretty healthy snack. One tub kept my dog busy for about 20 minutes. I don’t know whether it was because it was a big enough tub that it filled him up or because he’s actually just a really slow eater.

We started off with the apple-flavoured ice cream with carrot pieces, which honestly smells pretty tasty, and has a really nice texture and colour to it. He was a little skeptical at first, pulling away from the little tub after giving it a sniff, but once I’d emptied it out into his bowl, he seemed to take to the cold treat (after a bit of coaxing).

He gave it a good sniff, but he was still a little skeptical
He gave it a good sniff, but he was still a little skeptical (Alex Lee)

While he did seem to enjoy it after a short time, it still took a few minutes to get comfortable with it, potentially because he’s never had a soft, whipped-like cold dessert like this before. He also made one thing very clear – fast. The fact that he really doesn’t like his veg, and that he wasn’t a fan of the little bits of carrot in the ice cream.

Gatsby picked out every bit of carrot in his scoop and spat some of them outside his bowl. He just lapped up all the creamy goodness itself. So while he seemed to like the flavour of the ice cream, he wasn’t a fan of the chunky bits.

The carrots picked out of the ice cream
The carrots picked out of the ice cream (Alex Lee)

After a few hours of rest, we tried the vanilla-flavoured ice cream with peas in it. I was certain he was going to enjoy this one more than the apple-flavoured one – he’s always seemed more vanilla than apple, and it smelt simply delicious, but boy was I wrong. He hated this one – loathed it. He gave it a sniff, one little lick, then trotted away.

Even sticking a biscuit into the ice cream itself didn’t fool him into gorging on the cold treat. He just picked up the biscuit in his mouth, chomped on it, smelt to see if there was any more biscuit remaining and went away. There was no way he was going to eat this ice cream monstrosity, especially if it had peas in it apparently.

The ice cream has a really nice consistency and smells delicious
The ice cream has a really nice consistency and smells delicious (Alex Lee)

The verdict: Aldi Beechdean doggy ice cream

Well, it wasn’t a runaway success in my household. While Gatsby seemed to somewhat enjoy the apple and carrot-flavoured ice cream, it took a bit of coaxing, and he wasn’t a fan of the pea and vanilla flavour. If your dog isn’t too fussed about their food, then there’s a good chance they’ll enjoy this, but if your pooch absolutely hates vegetables – this is a plant-based product after all – good luck. Even though my dog tries desperately to get a lick of my non-vegan ice cream, he didn’t seem a massive fan of Aldi’s one designed for him.

You do get a good amount of ice cream for the price – £2.99 isn’t a lot for four tubs of ice cream, just be prepared for your pooch not to be enamoured with the product. The key takeaway was that it did actually cool him down. He was panting heavily before licking up his apple (sans carrot) ice cream, and seemed a lot less agitated and hot after his meal. Give it a go.

The Aldi Beechdean doggy ice cream is currently available to buy in-store now.

Voucher codes

For the latest discounts on dog food and all those other pet essentials, click the links below:

For more pooch content, read our guide to choosing the right food for your pup

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in