
The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?
We spent months testing products for brighter teeth – here are the ones that impressed us the most
Teeth whitening is one of the most common at-home beauty treatments. Teeth discolouration is never fun and can affect people’s confidence, caused by drinking tea, coffee, juice and wine. It can even be a side effect of some medicines.
Many people go to their dentist for a spot of teeth whitening, but this can be pretty expensive. If you’re on a budget or don’t have the time for a trip to the dentist, you’ll be glad to hear that there are some quick and easy DIY teeth whitening kits available to use at home.
However, here in the UK, teeth whitening kits are strictly regulated. Hydrogen peroxide is the most common ingredient in teeth whitening kits, but it can cause sensitivity issues, so it’s regulated in the UK. That means that British teeth whitening kits aren’t as powerful as kits sold in the rest of the world.
In fact, according to cosmetic dentist Dr Sahil Patel, “Over-the-counter kits in the UK can only have up to 0.1 per cent hydrogen peroxide, while US kits often contain much higher concentrations (sometimes up to 6 per cent, or more).” While professional in-dentist treatments are always an option for deep discolouration, Dr Patel says that at-home formulas can be “effective for surface stains”.
The question is: which at-home teeth whitening kits are worth your time and money? There are dozens of kits on the market, each with different formulas, application methods, and price points. I set out to track down the best teeth whitening kits, from gels to powders and everything in between.
After researching whitening strips, pens, toothpastes and more, I got to work testing a range of teeth whitening kits to see if they could banish surface stains from coffee, juice and tea. Keep scrolling for my full review and verdict.
After reviewing negative customer feedback and narrowing down my selection of whitening products, I tested a shortlist of treatments over several months. I followed each brand’s guidelines and tailored my use to their instructions. I didn’t take ‘before and after’ photos during testing because, as my teeth became progressively whiter after testing consecutive products, the photos might have made the results of the first test appear better than they actually were. In reality, the first product I tested had more stains to work with, which made its initial effect seem more noticeable. For each formula, I paid attention to comfort (including teeth sensitivity), ease of use and, of course, effectiveness.
As a beauty writer, my years in product reviewing have left me well informed about oral hygiene and dental aesthetics. When it came to assessing the best teeth whitening kits, I sought advice from an experienced dentist, combining his advice with real-world testing to find the formulas that are worth your time and money.
This LED kit offers great value for money, with enough formula for 30 treatments. It boasts three times more ‘activator’ lights than competitors and, while I can neither confirm nor deny this claim (the exact number hasn’t been stated), I was pleased to learn of the triple LED functionality. The blue light aims to break down stains by speeding up the PAP (phthalimidoperoxycaproic acid) oxidisation process, while the brand claims that the red light will boost comfort by minimising bacteria, gum inflammation and tooth sensitivity. Users can even combine the red and blue lights at once.
Using the kit is as simple as applying the formula to your teeth, inserting the mouth tray, and activating your chosen light setting for 10-30 minutes. The mouth tray is comfortable to wear and, while the full 30 minutes is a bit of a jaw workout, the brand claims you’ll see results after seven days of 10-minute treatments, too. In fact, I saw my teeth getting brighter (judging by the shade guide included) after just one 30-minute session. My one gripe? Even the slightest nudge to the touch-activated power button will turn off the device.
If you’ve ever seen the social media marketing for Hismile’s colour corrector serum, you might be intrigued by its promise of instant whitening. I’m pleased to confirm that the serum works instantly, but it doesn’t have a long-lasting effect.
I tested it on one side of my mouth to see if I could detect any difference in tone between the left and right halves. After just a couple of minutes of working the product onto my teeth with a cotton swab, it was clear the side with the serum had brightened.
However, the next morning, my teeth had returned to normal, and both sides were back to the same shade of white. I also found that working the serum into every tooth for 30 seconds – as Hismile recommends – required quite a bit of armwork and around seven minutes of application in total - and that’s just for all your visible teeth.
For a night out or a special occasion, this colour corrector could be a great option. If you’re looking to do away with years of staining, this might not be the product for you.
I loved this brand’s LED mouthguard. It features everything from magnetic charging to easy ‘clench-free’ positioning, and it sits comfortably around your teeth and gums so you don’t need to strain your jaw to hold everything in place.
Whitening with this kit can be broken into four parts. Firstly, you apply the self-adhering whitening strips to the upper and lower teeth. After inserting the mouthguard, you then activate the LED function, which will operate for 10 minutes in a blue light mode (for accelerated whitening). Once the blue light times out, you can begin five minutes of gum health-boosting red light. Lastly, after leaving the strips in place for another 15 minutes, you can touch up with the included pen. This stage is designed to be used as an intermediary top-up after the 10-day treatment, but I did give it a go throughout the process, too.
After just one day of using this kit, I could see some patches looked whiter and, after the full 10 days of treatment, my teeth certainly lifted in colour by a shade or two. Admittedly, I don’t think the pen made a noticeable difference, and I found it hard to follow the brand’s ‘don’t swallow’ advice when actively swiping the pen across all my teeth. Additionally, I found the whitening strips, while non-slippy, for easy application, adhered to my teeth a bit too well, which made removing them a little uncomfortable.
On the whole, I found this kit effectively whitened my teeth, and the addition of the red light feature to reduce sensitivity was a bonus for my ice-cream averse front teeth.
Though I found this kit the least enjoyable to use, it was also the most effective. You apply a clear serum to dry teeth (which requires tissue and some serious grimacing while you hold your lips back) before using an LED shield for 10 minutes.
However, the whole process was uncomfortable. You have to clench your jaw to keep the LED shield in place, and I often had to adjust it. The process needs to be repeated twice daily after brushing your teeth, which is a little inconvenient, and it leaves a plastic film on the surface of your teeth. The brand says that you only need to rinse your mouth with water afterwards, but I found that it clings to your teeth. Every time I used this kit, I had to brush my teeth a second time to get rid of the serum.
That sounds like a lot of faff, but I can’t deny the effectiveness of the product. My teeth appeared brighter and whiter after just a couple of treatments, and, with the kit often on offer for less than £50, I think it’s worth the hassle. Just make sure you’ve got two weeks in which you can squeeze the daily 20-minute treatments.
Much like Spotlight’s LED mouthguard, this Icy Bear device is easy to wear, and the charge lasts for the full seven-day treatment. The application process is simple. All you have to do is inject one-third of a gel syringe in total across the top and bottom portions of the tray. After that, pop the tray in your mouth, activate the 10-minute LED treatment and sit for 10-20 minutes while the gel works its magic.
When you remove the mouthguard, you can see immediately that your teeth are glowing from the light-scattering titanium dioxide. This makes it a good choice if you want to brighten your teeth before an event.
However, the effect is only temporary. My teeth lifted a shade between days one and seven, but the gel tends to sink to the bottom of the tray, so I don’t think the colour difference was as intense as it could have been.
The final 10 minutes of wearing the tray may cause your jaw to clamp up, but the fact that the mouthguard can be separated from the battery pack makes this easy to clean. Overall, I think this kit is well priced for what it offers, as I saw results over a relatively short period.
Renowned for its LED face mask, Currentbody also has an LED whitening kit. Having tested the brand’s series one, two, and anti-blemish face masks, I’m well acquainted with its expertise in all things red, near-infrared and blue light – and it’s these wavelengths that make Currentbody’s whitening approach unique.
While the red and near-infrared light frequencies lower sensitivity by boosting cell renewal and healing, the blue light is designed to tackle oral bacteria to minimise bad breath. Together with the PAP (phthalimidoperoxycaproic acid), the kit is simultaneously tough on stains and gentle on enamel and gums. For me, Currentbody’s mouth tray was the comfiest I’ve tried, and the six-day use time wasn’t too long. Admittedly, 20 minutes is quite a long time to keep the device in your mouth but, given it’s wireless, it’s no hassle to watch TV or load a dishwasher while wearing it.
At the end of the testing period, the whiteness of my teeth had improved, and my results were similar to those on the brand’s website. The brilliance of the white had certainly been boosted, but the shade difference was fairly subtle. The kit includes enough gel doses for 12 sessions, so you can complete another full cycle further down the line.
This set includes both whitening strips and a whitening pen, so it’s excellent value. You get two products for less than the kits in most of this guide.
The no-frills whitening strips are hassle-free. There’s no recharging, and you don’t need to play dentist with a collection of syringes. Simply apply two strips – one for the top row and one for the bottom row of teeth – and you’re good to go. That said, applying the bottom strip can be tricky, as saliva may cause it to dissolve too quickly. I also found I couldn’t talk without worrying about disturbing the gel. On the bright side, the pleasant mint flavour eliminates the need for rinsing after application.
As for the whitening pen, I used it at night and noticed a visible improvement in the brightness of my teeth by morning. However, the effect was more of a temporary glow rather than a lasting change.
Long-term, I found the strips prevented dulling and gave my teeth an enhanced shine. That said, they might not be the best choice for those with deep-set stains from years of smoking or drinking coffee.
This teeth whitening trio offers a sleek approach to oral health and aesthetics, targeting bad breath, food stains and mouth sensitivity. Created by Dr Mahsa Shoaie, it’s designed as a follow-up treatment to “enhance” and “maintain” results from her in-chair whitening procedure at her clinic, Nejati. However, I used this one as a standalone kit.
As someone prone to dehydration – and the bad breath that comes with it – I enlisted my partner to help monitor any stale or sour mouth odours while I tested Mahsa’s oral serum pen and LED (red light mode) kit. Though not the most glamorous task, he was pleased to report no foul odours, even after I had coffee, which is usually the culprit.
Thanks to the charcoal in the toothpaste, the kit provides an instant whitening boost by absorbing surface stains from things such as red wine and curry. The combination of whitening pen and blue LED is key for more stubborn discolouration.
The blue light is meant to speed up the hydrogen peroxide, breaking down stains, and, although I’ve experienced sensitivity from hydrogen peroxide in the past, I didn’t have any discomfort with Mahsa’s formula. This is likely due to the low concentration (0.1 per cent), which also explains the subtle results. Overall, Mahsa’s kit provided a gentle but effective approach. However, it’s expensive.
Teeth whitening kits can include whitening pens, powders, gels and strips. Strips are applied straight onto your teeth after you’ve brushed them, while powders can be applied with a toothbrush. Alternatively, whitening pens are portable and easy to use when you’re on the go. Some whitening treatments will come with a mouth tray and an LED light, which helps to speed up the whitening effect.
Hydrogen peroxide and carbamide peroxide are common active ingredients because of their bleaching effect on teeth. While at-home kits contain lower concentrations of peroxide than teeth whitening treatments from dentists, some people may be wary of the risks of using peroxide at home.
These can include issues around sensitivity, which are caused by damage to the tooth enamel. If you want to go peroxide-free, consider formulas with other active ingredients, such as phthalimidoperoxycaproic acid, pentasodium triphosphate, sodium chlorite or coconut oil, among others.
To ensure your at-home teeth whitening is safe, follow the directions carefully. Don’t leave the solution on longer than the brand advises, as this may irritate gums. If so, stop the treatment. It’s also recommended that pregnant or breastfeeding women should not use teeth whitening kits.
Activated charcoal is a less synthetic solution than hydrogen peroxide. However, some sources say charcoal’s abrasive texture could wear down tooth enamel, so while it can whiten teeth, it can also damage them.
The amount of time it will take to whiten teeth will depend on the product and the amount of staining on your teeth. With most solutions, you’ll notice a difference after two weeks.
You can top up your whitening when you feel the initial effect has started to fade. How long this will take depends on your diet and dental care. Always check the instructions on the package, as each kit is different, and overuse of whitening kits can cause tooth sensitivity, inflamed gums and enamel erosion.
These kits use light-emitting diodes (LEDs) to emit ultraviolet and infrared light. These lights, particularly UV light, activate teeth whitening agents – gels, for example – and are said to make them work faster. So, while the LED itself doesn’t whiten teeth, Dr Patel says “it helps speed up the whitening process”.
Teeth whitening strips work, but Dr Patel says “The results depend on the brand and how stained your teeth are to begin with.” He explained that while peroxide-based strips can brighten teeth over time, he warns that “They’re usually more effective for surface stains, rather than deep discolouration.”
Across both LED and strip-based teeth whitening, Dr Patel agrees that opting for a reputable brand and following its guidelines is crucial. “Some kits contain stronger whitening agents that could cause irritation or sensitivity, especially if used too often. It’s good to start slow,” he says.
Many things cause teeth staining. Dr Patel warns against:
• Tea and coffee – “Tannins in these drinks stick to enamel and cause yellowing.”
• Red wine – “The deep colour and acidity can stain teeth over time.”
• Smoking – “Nicotine and tar turn teeth yellow and brown.”
• Sugary and acidic foods – “These weaken enamel, making teeth more prone to staining.”
• Poor oral hygiene – “If plaque builds up, stains can set in more easily.”
• Ageing – “Enamel naturally wears down over time, making the yellowish dentin underneath more visible.”
Annoyingly, you need to be careful after teeth whitening, confirms Patel. “After whitening, your teeth are more porous, so it’s best to avoid stain-causing foods and drinks (like coffee, tea, red wine, and curry) for at least 24-48 hours. Stick to lighter-coloured foods like chicken, rice, and dairy, if you want to be extra careful.”
Overall, Smilepro’s LED and pen kit emerged as the best teeth whitening product, offering great value and effectiveness. Spotlight Oral Care’s strips and LED kit came in a close second, delivering noticeable results at a slightly higher price. For an affordable and quick solution, Colgate’s max white treatment was a strong contender. Meanwhile, Hismile provided an instant glow, and Icy Bear gave a pearly white finish, although neither kit led to a dramatic difference or long-lasting brightness.
Want to add extra oomph to your smile? These are the best teeth whitening toothpastes