Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

9 best Christmas desserts if a traditional pudding isn’t for you

From creamy gelato to vegan cheesecake or chocolate profiteroles, we’ve found something for everyone

Stacey Smith
Friday 04 December 2020 11:38 GMT
There’s always room for a much-loved profiterole
There’s always room for a much-loved profiterole (The Independent/iStock)

Who said the turkey was the only centrepiece worth thinking about? We’ve found the best desserts to ensure you round off your Christmas feast on a sweet high.

We’ve focussed purely on proper desserts here. We know Christmas puddings and cakes are the traditional options but in our experience, they are just too heavy and rarely tend to be a hit with the whole family – unlike this selection which we’re certain will go down a treat!

When putting our festive afters to the test, we were looking for those that had the wow factor. 

They needed to look better than the winning GBBO entry and taste every bit as good. Festive spices or retro flavours were a plus, as were OTT decorations. 

If you can’t be a little decadent at Christmas, when can you?

Although most can simply be taken out of the fridge and served, we also couldn’t resist one DIY option. Ideal if you fancy getting your hands dirty – but not that dirty. Who’s got time to make dessert from scratch with everything else to remember anyway?

We tend to think the brands’ serving suggestions are often a tad optimistic. If you want to ensure there’s plenty to go around, we’d suggest erring on the side of caution and sizing up, or buying double.

So, whatever size gathering you’re having, we’ve got a show-stopping festive dessert for you…

You can trust our independent reviews. We may earn commission from some of the retailers, but we never allow this to influence selections. This revenue helps us to fund journalism across The Independent.

Waitrose queen of trifles 600g (serves 10)

Waitrose Queen of Trifles 600g (serves 10)IndyBest, Waitrose copy.jpg

Made up of pretty layers, this elegant dessert looks like something you’d find in a posh Parisian patisserie. There’s sherry-soaked sponge, wobbly raspberry jelly, creamy vanilla custard and a sprinkling of meringue and pistachio for added texture. Forget the kitsch trifles of your youth, this is full-flavoured but deliciously light, and a knock-out way to round-off your Christmas feast.

  1. £15 from Waitrose
Prices may vary
Back to top

Taste the Difference tiramichoux dessert 746g (serves 8)

Taste the Difference Tiramichou IndyBest Dessert 746g (serves 8) Sainsburys.jpg

Christmas is all about indulgence – so why have one dessert when you could have two? The development team at Sainsbury’s has combined the delicious coffee-soaked sponge flavours of tiramisu with light, cream-filled profiteroles. There are delicious little pockets of chocolate mousse too and it’s topped with chocolate shavings. Coffee, cream and choux? Sainsbury’s has 'nailed the Christmas day dessert. Although Sainsbury’s say it serves eight, we reckon it’s more six to eight people, depending on how full you are from the turkey.

Back to top

Iceland millionaire salted caramel gold bar cheesecake 652g (serves 6)

Iceland Millionaire Salted Caramel Gold Bar IndyBest Cheesecake 652g (serves 6), Iceland.jpg

Everyone loves cheesecake but Iceland has taken inspiration from a gold bullion bar for their festive spin on this one. We loved the soft biscuit base, creamy caramel middle and layer of salted caramel sauce. The Belgium chocolate slab topper is also delicious but it does make serving even slices a little tricky, as it cracks under the knife. We’d be tempted to just pop the whole thing in the middle of the table and let everyone dive in. It arrives frozen and will need two-hours to thaw, so do factor that into your prep time. And this will easily serve six people, well done Iceland!

  1. £5 from Iceland
Prices may vary
Back to top

M&S Collection golden balls 620g (serves 8)

M&S Collection Golden Balls 620g (serves 8) IndyBest, Marks and Spencer.jpg

As much as we’d love David Beckham waiting for us under the tree this Christmas, these golden balls from M&S are probably as close as we’re going to get to the real deal. There’s always room for a much-loved profiterole and this stack contains 30 light choux pastries, filled with cream and covered with salted caramel, mini golden malteser-type balls and a gold lustre. Although if you split the balls evenly, according to the brand’s serving suggestion, each person will end up with 3.75 pieces each. Good luck dishing that one up!  

Back to top

Cook chocolate and caramel wreath 1040g (serves 10-12)

Cook Chocolate & Caramel Wreath 1040g (serves 10-12) Cook IndyBest.jpg

This festive sweet wreath is a combination of crowd-pleasing marbled vanilla and chocolate sponge and chocolate mousse, covered with whipped cream. We can’t imagine anyone could resist a slice. It’s topped with more caramel and chocolate drizzle, milk chocolate toffee balls, shards of dark chocolate and gold lustre. The only thing we would say is, it’s all quite beige. To brighten it up a bit, the brand suggests serving with fresh raspberries. We must be particularly greedy because we can’t see this serving more than eight people.

  1. £18 from Cook
Prices may vary
Back to top

Mr Prempy’s orange and Christmas spice dessert 850g

Mr Prempys Orange & Christmas Spice Dessert 850g IndyBest, Abel & Cole.jpg

Organic, vegan and utterly delicious, whether you follow a plant-based lifestyle or not, this dairy-free cheesecake, is sure to wow. The “cheese” bit is made with cashew nuts and it’s infused with festive spices such as nutmeg and cinnamon, along with fresh orange juice and zest – it smells amazing. Handmade (just not with your fair hands), it’s free from refined sugar too, using just the natural sweetness of maple syrup. All in all, this is every bit as indulgent as you’d want Christmas dessert to be and we loved it. They don’t say how many it serves but we think you’ll easily get six to eight slices out of it, as it’s quite rich.

Back to top

Tesco Finest chocolate orange and maple bauble cake 1080g (serves 14)

Tesco Finest Chocolate Orange & Maple Bauble IndyBest Cake 1080g (serves 14), Tesco.jpg

With a convincing-looking chocolate bauble decoration, this is quite the centrepiece. We loved that the centre spilled out to reveal chocolate balls when you cut into it – this is definitely one to dish out at the table. The rich chocolate orange sponge is decorated with sweet maple buttercream and although probably a little too heavy for after Christmas lunch, we reckon this is a great cake to have on standby during the festive season – we’re sure you’ll find an occasion.

  1. £13 from Tesco
Prices may vary
Back to top

Pleesecake build your own Saint Nicks surprise (8-10): £38, Pleesecake

Pleesecake Build Your Own Saint Nicks Surprise IndyBest (serves 8-10) , Pleesecake.jpg

This DIY kit is a great alternative to making dessert from scratch (but don’t worry, you’ll still get all the credit). Fun for the whole family, each pack contains a frozen cheesecake ready to be topped with treats. With chocolate shards, ganache and cookie dough, there’s even mini mince pies, candy canes and edible snow to really make this a Christmas dessert to remember. Entertaining and delicious, what’s not to love! There are only 100 kits available though, so if you want in, you’ll need to move fast.

  1. £38 from Pleesecake
Prices may vary
Back to top

The verdict: Christmas desserts

Waitrose’s queen of trifles is everything a great Christmas dessert should be. Beautiful, vibrant layers, a modern take on retro flavours and light enough for a slice after the main event. We’re also huge fans of Hackney Gelato’s limited-edition flavours – if you can get your hand on a tub it’s well worth keeping in the freezer (not that it’ll last that long!)

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in