Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

9 best plastic-free Easter eggs that are easy to recycle

As little as just a third of the entire weight of the product was only chocolate

Emma Henderson
Thursday 02 April 2020 18:03 BST
Enjoy more of the good stuff using materials that are easier to reuse again
Enjoy more of the good stuff using materials that are easier to reuse again (iStock/ The Independent)
Our Top Picks

A shop-bought Easter egg is synonymous with a cardboard box and a huge plastic mould around the egg. And the bigger the egg, the more plastic it has.

Although, when customers started to question why the eggs came with so much packaging, brands defended the choice by saying it was for protection. But in reality, it is excessive use of single use plastic.

In 2018, it was reported that up to a third of the weight of some Easter eggs was just the packaging – both cardboard and plastic. Foil is of course recyclable, and is best done by cleaning it, if need be, and scrunching it in a ball, according to Recycle Now, the national recycling campaign for England.

This year, Asda announced that it is reducing 98 per cent of its plastic across its Extra Special Easter egg range – that’s equivalent to 16 tonnes.

Read more: Best Easter egg deals

It’s part of the supermarket’s commitment to “reduce, reuse and recycle” more, and hopes to make its own brand packaging 100 per cent recyclable before it’s target of 2025.

The brand has changed the shape of its eggs to better fit the cardboard box – which is recyclable – but hasn’t reduced the amount of chocolate, thank goodness, so it’s a win win for chocolate fans who want to be more eco.

You can trust our independent reviews. We may earn commission from some of the retailers, but we never allow this to influence selections, which are formed from real-world testing and expert advice. This revenue helps to fund journalism across The Independent.

1
Asda extra special Easter egg, 245g

eggs.jpg

This thick and creamy egg with a hint of orange went down an absolute storm in our office. Made with Belgian milk chocolate, the orange pattern is a crunchy contrast to the rest of the egg, which is hand decorated. It’s essentially a chocolate orange in Easter form, and the quality far exceeds the tiny price tag. It’s an absolute bargain, and we’re finding it hard to not be greedy and buy a few. The plastic-looking film in the box is compostable and there’s a cardboard support at the bottom to keep it in place.

  1.  £5 from Asda
Prices may vary
Back to top

2
Daylesford praline chocolate farm animals, 104g

daylesford-praline-animals-indybest.jpg

This one’s not an egg shape, but we love these cute little spring-time animals, which include two white chocolate lambs, two milk chocolate bunnies and two marbled chocolate lambs in a little box full of make-shift straw, in entirely recyclable packaging. The praline chocolate has a hint of hazelnut, is ethically sourced from the Grenada Chocolate company and is wonderfully creamy and decadent. We assure you these won’t hang around for long.

  1.  £9 from Daylesford
Prices may vary
Back to top

3
Montezuma milk chocolate Charlie chick with buttons, 100g

charlie-chick-eastr-egg-indybest.jpg

The brand claims to be the only chocolate company that’s managed to convert its entire range to sustainable packaging – which is either recyclable or biodegradable – as of February 2020. The smooth and creamy milk chocolate of this cheery chick-shaped egg is hard to stop eating, and we loved the large buttons that come with it, too. It’s also one of the only eggs not to include tinfoil.

  1.  £6 from Montezuma
Prices may vary
Back to top

4
Love Cocoa limited edition salted caramel Easter egg, 150g

love-cocoa-easter-egg-indybest.jpg

Founded by James Cadbury in 2016, Love Cocoa’s egg has already sold out from most stockists – and we know why: it’s one of the best tasting eggs on the list. It didn’t hang around for long with us either. Coming in this lovely spring-coloured cardboard box – which we’re reusing to store pens – it’s made from 70 per cent organic cacao from Columbia, which has been fairly traded. The chocolate is handmade, has a hint of sea salt and is absolutely delicious.

  1.  £11 from Trouva
Prices may vary
Back to top

5
Tony’s Chocolonely mini egg carton

tonys-chocolonely-mini-eggs-indybest.jpg

From the brand that’s trying to eradicate slavery from the chocolate supply chain – it has unequal squares on its chocolate bars to show the disproportionate money involved from grower to buyer – are these lovely brightly coloured mini eggs. The cardboard carton has spread seven flavours across the 12 eggs: milk chocolate, dark chocolate, nougat, hazelnut, caramel sea salt, almond sea salt and pretzel toffee. Our favourite is the almond sea salt. The eggs may be mini, but mighty in flavour.

  1.  £4 from Selfridges
Prices may vary
Back to top

6
Chocolarder gorse flower, 185g

chocolarder-gorse-flower-indybest.jpg

This egg comes in a seriously protective cardboard hexagon design – which we’re seeing more and more of – and shows how there’s absolutely no need for plastic to protect anything. It’s easy to remove and keep in tact to reuse too. This egg has the most unusual ingredient in our list: yellow gorse flower picked from hedgerows in Cornwall, which gives a lightly toasted coconutty flavour to the to 50 per cent milk chocolate. It’s delicate, delicious and innovative in packaging design as well as flavour.

Back to top

7
Fortnum & Mason children’s milk chocolate chicken Easter egg

fm-chicken-chocolate-easter-egg-indybest.jpg

Although it says it’s for kids, we’re pretty sure anyone – adults included – would love to receive this lovely egg. Coming in just a cardboard box – that’s ever so pretty – this milk chocolate egg is covered in gold tinfoil, has three cute little chicks, a gold-dusted egg inside and is packed with brown shredded paper. The smooth chocolate egg is creamy, thick and good quality. It’s also available in dark chocolate with little bunnies inside.

Back to top

8
Cox & Co 61% Colombian cacao bee pollen and honey Easter egg, 170g

cco-pollen-honey-easter-egg-indybest.jpg

Born from the idea of making chocolate as ethical and sustainable as possible, all the chocolate from this brand – which was set up by Gavin Cox who grew up in South America – comes from the Casa Luker estate in Colombia. The estate’s supply chain is traceable and it invests not only in its farmers and environmental farming methods, but the communities too. The egg combines bee pollen with honey, which gives the dark chocolate a little sweetness. It’s grown up and pretty innovative. The packaging is fully biodegradable cardboard that uses vegetable based inks and all the illustrations are drawn by Gavin’s mum, Dawn.

  1.  £10 from Cox & Co.
Prices may vary
Back to top

The verdict: Plastic-free Easter egg

The Asda extra special orange chocolate egg wins our best buy, not only for it’s great taste and design, but it’s also the best value and has the most chocolate – which is obviously key for all us chocoholics.

We also loved the Love Coca salted caramel egg, for it’s delicate, moreish flavour. Chocolader’s innovative packaging is the best we’ve seen, and we also loved it’s ingenious use of flavour.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in